The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 5 · May 1907
194printed page
scan 34 of 52

EDITORIAL PAGES.

ligion which it will take years to heal. The Hebrew Union College is their property, but have they the right to damage the property beyond repair?

They cannot muzzle public opinion. They should not expect public opinion to characterize their conduct as anything better than what would have been done by a Baptist seminary or a Catholic university, with the papal index in force. The Hebrew Union College will not be considered as a aniversity of Jewish science, but as a private institution for the creation of rabbis who have already denied the validity of post-biblical literature, the Shulkan Aruch, Zionism, Zion, a greater part of the Bible, and who are expected to cling with all the strength of their souls only to a few sayings of the prophets and a judicious selection {rom the Ten Commandments.

The world will say, too, that that man is unworthy of being the head of learning who undertakes to oppress the growth of a positive faith in Jewish life, a faith which has rejuvenated Jewish ideals, reclaimed thousands who had turned in disgust from the cant of self-abasement coupled with the cant of self-glorification, and has made the Jewish future a thing in which to rejoice. The world will say that a movement which has been declared as ossified takes the worst possible measure for the refutation of that charge when it undertakes, in the 20th century in a free country, to employ the methods that are the root of all the evils of oppression and persecution. Liberalism means something more than the mere mouthing of the word by intolerant dogmatists.

Reform Judaism has made its choice. If it speaks uncontradicted, its choice is the choice of death, intensive deformity, and utter ossification beyond peradventure.

NORDAU AND MARMOREK.

To use the conventional language of political campaigns, Dr. Max Nordau has "sounded the first note" in the debate which

will occupy the attention of the next Congress. The issue is unavoidable. Our ranks are divided between those who would conquer for Zionism by settlements in Palestine, and those who would master Palestine in order to make settlements practical. The lines are not as finely drawn as when Dr. Herzl first threw down the gage to the Chovevi Zion The newer work has been animated by a greater spirit and has had a more general purpose than when little colonies were added to little colonies, but the broad distinction is the same. Yet the Gegenswart program is not on the great lines which Herzl sketched, and which alone meet the real Tewish need.

There is, however, little likelihood of serious discussion. Compromise is already in the air, and for this reason it is all the more possible to discuss the varying programs frankly and freely. No doubt, American Zionism will do its share towards crystallizing opinion at the ensuing convention.

THE JEWS IN ROUMANIA.

We have been excited needlessiy. The Roumamian Jews are not the victims of anti-Semitic outrages, but of the excessive warspirit of the Roumanian peasants. Of course, if they had been the vietims of anti-Semitism, our American Jewish Committee, and the Russo-Jewish Committee, might have done something. They might have petitioned the Brit:sh Government to remonstrate with Roumania, and compel its cowardly Government to give the Jews those rights guaranteed by the Berlin Treaty. Mass-meetings might have been held and resolutions carried. and fiery speeches might have been delivered.

But what can we do to prevent the peasants from making “a heap of ashes” of our poor brethren? AI that ıs beyond the pale of diplomacy. If we have gone ahead assuming that the Government is responsible, we beg the Government's pardon. It is In the same boat with us: the peasants cannot be controlled.