The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
211printed page
scan 11 of 54

the opportunity which has been so long withheld, the opportunity for social, economic and political privilege. The consequence is almost inevitable; abandoning his own traditions for the sake of the opportunity, he takes on the vulgarity of his time. For vulgarity after all means lack of background, the absence of ideal elements in life. Almost any adopted manners will be vulgar, because they will be external, without any symbolic meaning.

Now to my mind, it is possible to draw a perfectly clear, practical conclusion from all "this, even should it be incapable of actual realization. Let me say that I do not find that this -conclusion is necessarily connected with the question of Zionism. There are so many wholly convincing arguments in favor of Zionism, that that question reduces itself almost entirely to one of expediency. But even so the question of the prospect which awaits the American and European Jew who is already irrevocably identified with the country of his ‘adoption, is left wholly untouched. How, for ‚example, are we to define a good American Jew? American Jews there will be in ever in-creasing numbers, ‘whatever be the outcome of the Palestinian or Territorialist agitation. The answer seems clear. The good American Jew will be the man who is a good American, possibly a better American than anyone has yet been, because he has the courage of the Judaısm which is within him. . -. - »

Indeed, it may be said that there is a pecu liar timeliness in these ideas, eternal though they be. The main source of social and national evil in our own time is the loss of respect for the elementary virtues. The great economic vice of the day is extravagance, the impatience that desires the fruit before the seed is matured. Such social evils as have given rise to the "divorce question," and even to doubt concerning the very institution of the family, may be traced mainly to a sort of pettishness which is a consequence of material success too easily attained. There is, then, abundant occasion for the preaching of the old proverbial wisdom. It is not only true, but urgently true that the way of life is the way of thrift,

temperance and justice. The Jews in America are already notable for their instinctive appreciation of this. No people has been so quick to recognize the real office of American institutions. The ’schools are crowded with Jewish children, whose parents are willing to make any sacrifice in order that they may fit themselves for life and improve their station. The Jewish vote is commonly cast for the sake of good government. The Jew knows what everyone really knows, but so easily forgets, that government is justified only through its providing certain necessary conditions of health, security and individual improvement. As respects the religious question it ought, I think, to be said that the Jews of the younger generation are facing problems which are by no means peculiar to themselves. The great perennial problem of liberal religion is the conservation of the ancient reverence amidst the unceasing disintegration of doctrine and ritual. The present age is an age of doubt and hesitation, but the essential religious truth is unmistakable and is shared by Jews and Christians alike. In religion, the moral will must be sustained; goodness must somehow be lifted up and made to command the reverence and devotion of all. This being the very essence of religion, I see no reason why the leaven of Judaism should not work toward promoting a revival of faith.

In conclusion let me emphasize what seems to me the best attitude which the Jew can take in all these matters. It is dangerous deliberately to place a tradition above an ideal. After all, we human beings have the most vital and important things in common. Not only are we connected by common material and political interests, but in the end the great problem of life is the same for all. It is dangerous to ınsist upon the personal pronoun in the matter of ideals. It is more important that ideals should prevail than that you or I should cause them to prevail. Thus, for Judaism, it ought to be more important that the world should see the light than that the Jews should reveal it. . . .