The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 6 · June 1907
231printed page
scan 31 of 54

The Zionist Observer

As To That Mission

THE other day, Commissioner Watchhorn attended a meeting of the American Tract Society and suggested that the Society confine its operations at Ellis Island to the eight hundred thousand Christian immigrants who pass through its portals annually, and not bewilder the two hundred thousand Jewish immigrants with Yiddish tracts on the merits of Christianity. The Society was shocked at the suggestion of persecution, and then decided to continue shooting its religious paper pellets at the incoming Jew. Plainly, the Society is stubborn and guilty of a most perverse and wasteful kind of folly.

Yet this kind of foolishness is the product of a self-conceived mission taken seriously. What nonsense, says the average type of Jew, to attempt to convert a people from one faith to another. Isn’t the Jew as good as a Christian, and if he isn’t, what better would he be by apostacy?

That is the burden of every fling at the conversionists in which the Jewish press indulges during the dull season. Yet Christianity sees it all in a different light. Palestine could easily have been purchased with the money wasted during the nineteenth century in attempts to teach the Jews the errors of their ways. Arabs, Mongols, Chinese and sundry other peoples knew of religion some centuries before the western nations first loomed upon the horizon of history. But Christianity does not think the money wasted. To do these futile things is part of its mission, which justifies its existence, and which by a mixed mental process at the same time proves it to be the best and the right religion.

The indictment against Christianity is that it preaches the beauty of humility and aggressively asserts its superiority. Now we Jews should recognize this position; it is

part of the whirling waters that have surrounded us for centuries upon centuries and forced separation upon us. Some Jewish ministers, snatching at a sentence and ignoring the whole life practice of its followers, have from time to time so lauded the Christian faith that the brotherhood of man seemed about to evolve itself in their pulpits. To them the Rev. Mr. Aked, the American Tract Society and mission schools are the proper and necessary Christian snub. Mr. Aked comes from a country where the church says very much what it feels in very plain English. His religion has taught him that everyone who does not accept Christianity is his spiritual inferior, and as a good man he is provided with a mission to raise all these ınferiors to his own soul level. That he has since retracted something of his first utterances on the soul value of non-Christian aliens, does not mean that he has altered his inherited opinions, but that he has begun to fall in line with our characteristic American habit of talking vaguely and ambiguousiy on serious problems calling for definite attrıbutes. For, and in this, lies the proof of our assertions, the A. T. C. and the mission schools are positive evidence that Christianity believes and practises what an Aked shouts from the housetops as its belief.

It is not our intention to belabor Christianity, for, after all, we only agree to disagree with it in the whole of its formulations as a practised faith. We have only sketched a certain situation in order to fit the boot on the other foot. Those who are most shocked at the mission proclamations of Christianity, bore us with the Jewish mission. According to the cutting assertion of Dr. Felsenthal, the Jewish mission is merely an apology for God in having dispersed us among the nations; according to other Jews, it is an apology for our existence to-day. We