The Maccabaean · Vol. XIII, No. 1 · July 1907
27printed page
scan 31 of 46

Reception to Dr. Magnes

The Zionist Council of Greater New York tendered a reception to Dr. J. L. Magnes prior to his departure for Palestine, on . Monday evening, June 10, at Clinton Hall. It was a remarkable testimonial of the affection of Zionists for Dr. Magnes. Clinton Hall was filled with about four hundred people. Zionist songs, Jewish folk songs, recitations and toasts filled the program for the evening.

Dr. J. Epstein, president of the Council, acted as toastmaster. Among those present were: Dr. David Blaustein. John Paley, Prof. Israel Friedlaender, Louis Miller, Mrs. and Miss Lewin-Epstein, David H. Lieberman, Herman Conheim, Louis Livingstone, Bernard G. Richards, Louis Lipsky, A. H. Fromenson, I. Prenskv and I. Kassel.

The speakers were: Professor Friedlaender, Dr. D. Blaustein, Bernard G. Richards, A. H. Fromenson, M. Levine, Louis Lipsky, John Paley and Dr. Ch. Wortsmann. Mr. Kassel read a letter from Sholom Aleichem, and also several sketches by the well known Yiddish writer. Between the speeches Platon Bruonoffs favored the audience with several compositions of his own, and a number of Yiddish folk songs, gathered by Mr. Kassel.

Sholom Aleichem’s letter read as follows:

"I have received the invitation to the reception to our beloved Dr. Magnes, to be given on the eve of his departure for Palestine. At the time when you will read these lines I, or rather my ship, 'New York,' will be fighting a battle with the waves of the Atlantic Ocean. Let the ship fight and let the captain knock his head against the walls, for all I care. For my part I will on the 10th of June drink a glass of wine in honor of our Dr. Magnes who is going to Palestine.

“I consider it a fortunate thing for the Jews of America that such a man as Dr. Magnes is going to visit the land of our fathers. Let our brethren in the Holy Land think that *Doctors’ in America, and not only doctor:, but all American Jews are as sympathetic, as simple in manner and as worthy of affection as is Dr. Magnes. I believe that those present at the reception will be sufhiciently endowed with wisdom as not to minconstrue my mean-

-ing and not feel offended by my words. When one speaks of the greatness of a certain artist, it should not give offense to all other artists, There are very many fine American people whom I know, and there are probably many more whom I have not had the opportunity to meet; but I like Dr. Magnes more than I do a great many other. people, and do I deserve any punishment for that? It is quite possible that I would not have said these things in his presence as I do in writing. But I hope that Dr. Magnes has already heard many good words about himself. He will not blush. He is not a girl, anyway, and neither am I a complimenting cavalier. May he have a happy journey and my wish for the gathering is that you may be able to entertain many such citizens of Palestine as is Dr. Magnes. With Zion’s greetings. SCHOLEM ALEICHEM.”

Dr. Magnes responded to the many expressions of esteem and affection in a speech which he has probably never excelled for sincerity and deep feeling. He wondered why Zionists assumed such an attitude of regard toward him. He knew that he and they had not done much. He was going to Palestine; but what was the reason for rejoicing? That should not be such an extraordinary event That he was going, not they, was mere chance. He agreed that they ought to envy him this trip.

Dr. Magnes spoke of what work there lies before Zionists. Zionism ought to take advantage of all phases of cultured life to stimulate Jewish consciousness. He said that the time would come when Zionism would have to meet local problems, too, and he believed that it would have to take some attitude toward Judaism. It would express, probably, a reform Judaism, but not the reform Judaism which favors assimilation. It would have to take into account the actuality of life, and formulate some religious expression on it.

The reception closed at a late hour with the singing of Zionist songs.

Dr. Magnes left New York on Wednesday, June 12. He will spend four weeks in Palestine, one week in Russia, and then attend the Zionist Congress. On the same day Mr. E. W. Lewin-Epstein, Dr. A. M. Radin, and Mr. A. Lubarsky also left for Europe.