THE COMMENTATOR
SUPERFLUOUS ORGAN.
Our readers have had such a sufficiency of reports of the Zionists’ Congress at the Hague in the daily papers, that we consider it unnecessary to reproduce them in our publication.—Jezwish Voice. ST. Louis,
WHY does the Jewish Voice make its appearance at all? The secular press gives as much attention to Jewish events as St. Louis reform Jews require, if not more than enough. The experiment might be made of suspending the publication of the Jewish Voice for several weeks, and then wait for a call that it be revived. Dr. Spitz might then enjoy a good long vacation.
DR. SILVERMAN REPUDIATES THE POPE.
Dr. J. SıLvErMmAN, of New York, is terribly angry with the Catholic Pope, who lives in Rome. In his Yom Kippur sermon he denounced the Pope’s dictum “that would tend to shunt the human race 1,000 years backward, and that makes for the upholding of a blind faith that can never bring happiness to humanity.” Why Jews should be interested in the encyclical of the head of the Catholic Church—and especially on Yom Kippur—only a reform and anti-Zionsst rabbi may be able to tell us. But it is safe to uphold Judaisnı by attacking Catholicism; that is a little better than denouncing Zionists as selfish misleaders —.and the Pope lives in Rome.
KILLING ROSENFELD.
THE Jewish press is so bound up with the love of the past, that it put the Yiddish poet, Morris Rosenfeld, six feet "into the earth" with the greatest satisfaction. Inasmuch as so many of our contemporaries are greatly disturbed when we speak of a distinct Jewish life, they may be trusted to make as much of
a Jewish death as even the best of us may expect. Rosenfeld expresses the wish that he may be permitted to write the obituary of the man who "killed him." Six feet deep will not be enough for him.
A DOUBLE INCOMPATIBILITY.
Dr. SAMUEL SCHULMAN goes Mr. Schiff one better in his opposition to Zionism. You may say Zionism is incompatible with Americanism. Why, it is contrary to Jewish “teachings.” How can a Zionist be a good Jew? The mental disease which makes this possible is beyond Dr. Schulman’s analysis, though he, too, like Dr. Silverman, finds :the selfishness of leaders at the bottom of all the trouble. But whose Jewish teachings is Dr. Schulman thinking of? His own, or Rabbi Reiness’? His own, or Dr. Schechters? His own, or the teachings of the ages, the prayers of the Jewish ritual? His own, or that of the unbroken line of Jewish tradition? When it is resolved into its own elements, it will be found that Dr. Schulman’s personal objection to Zionism, with its roots in the temporary German reform aberration, is all the authority he can find.
A suggestion may be pardoned: It is not becoming in the rabbi of Temple Beth-El, who has had some ambition to occupy the pulpit of Tempel Emanu-El, to select as the object of his personal attack, the rabbi of Temple Emanu-El, who has had the courage and the dignity and the sincerity to stand for the principles of Zionism in that important position. Dr. Schulman may be a good “German” reform rabbi, but he has not assimilated as yet the refinement and the courtesy which has always been one of the admirable traits of German Jews.