The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · October 1907
142printed page
scan 3 of 52

Dr. Silverman's Malicious Libel

DR. JOSEPH SILVERMAN, of Temple Emanuel, has hitherto been an opponent of Zionism, but, when in New York, has wisely refrained from personal abuse, limiting himself to the repudiation of Zionist principles. We are surprised to read, however, that he speaks altogether in a different vein when he leaves his home city. In the Savannah Morning News of September 4, he attacks the motives of Zionist leaders, and launches into personal abuse. This is what he said:

“We reject emphatically any idea of desiring a country or nation for the Hebrews, and we know that any attempt to create a sentiment favoring the establishment of a Hebrew nation is built on a foundation of sand. But, without reflecting on the local citizens, whether they be Hebrews or Gentiles, that there are a few individuals who profit and hope to continue profiting by appealing to this false, chimerical and destructive sentiment we have unquestioned proof.

“This element of Hebrews and others who seek to gain their. own ends, which are political and financial, are for the most part publishers, agitators of this pernicious doctrine, and landspeculators in Palestine This may sound far-fetched, but the proof is there for him who wants it. A certain line of Hebrew periodicals are constantly reverting to the old and abandoned idea of a Hebrew nation, the agitators assist them and the land owners in Palestine also join hands.”

Dr. Silverman’s arguments against Zionism were disposed of a few years ago by Jacob de Haas, and ever since then he has been extremely cautious as to what he was about to say on Zionism. “The burnt child dreads the fire.” Probably he thought that a voice shouting in Savannah is indeed a voice in the

wilderness, and beyond the pale of civilized interest, but the power of the press is enormotfs, and Dr. Silverman’s words have been read by a large number of interested readers, Jews and Gentiles. We have no concern with the impression made upon the Jewish people by this utterance of the senior rabbi of Temple Emanu-El, for Jews know too well that Zionist leaders have not been self-seekers, that they have not stirred up agitation to serve their own ends, that they have not been actuated by the selfishness of land-speculation. They know of the self-sacrifice of a Theodor Herzl, of a David Wolffsohn, of a Max Nordau, and of that large army of unnamed heroes whose bones fertilize. the soil of Palestine. They will not be influenced by such libelous statements. But, like everything else Dr. Silverman says, his remarks are intended to influence Gentiles. Because they do not know him, that influence may be great, and it is because of this fact that we call upon Dr. Silverman to justify his statement, to prove, if he can, that Zionism is a movement composed of “publishers, agitators, land-speculators, who seek their own ends.”

We know that Dr. Silverman would not dare to repeat these observations in New York City. We know that Dr. Silverman has never dared to go so far in his scandalous opposition to the Zionist movement. It is impossible to understand the motives that have prompted him to this outburst of ignorant fanaticism, but we are of the opinion that he owes it to his own reputation in New York City, where the leaders of the Zionist movement are as well-known as he, to modify or withdraw a statement based upon malicious untruth.

Dr. Silverman owes Zionism a retraction and an apology.