The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · October 1907
148printed page
scan 8 of 52

The modern Jew, whose development has kept pace with the development of the modern theories of nationalism, is no longer, like his predecessor of the "Haskoloh" periods, anxious to rid himself of his racial habits and peculiarities. He believes that these very peculiarities are a national asset, the creation and the assertion of his peculiar genius, which he would fain strengthen, but never, never abandon. This distinctive racial genius can only be fostered in a territory which, aside from its historical importance and inspiring remembrances, shall be exclusively settled by the people who possess that brand of culture in order that the constantly ensuing clash with the dominant all-devouring culture shall be eliminated.

As to the second assertion, that the Jews are merely a religious community, though it be but a rehash of an ancient nostrum, repeatedly enunciated since the very beginning of the reform movement in Germany, and equally as often refuted and driven from the field, still I would like to ask the distinguished lecturer a few questions, believing as I do that he is no mere monger of phrases, like some of our hypocritical rabbis who have originated and still repeat this hollow formula, with the nonchalance of the pious Buddhist as he makes the numberless revolution on his prayer-wheel, but is a sincere believer in the utterances of his lips and a real well-wisher of his "co-religionists."

Since you are quite ready to admit that there is the "origin of common ancestry," what, pray, has caused it to dissolve and us to be converted into a "religious community?" Is it due to our dispersion and lengthy settlement amongst the nations and the consequent adoption of their numerous and various customs? But these are only superficial and skin-deep, and if you probe deeper you discover the unmistakable Jewish traits the same the world over. Then, again, if our only affinity is based on the kinship of common belief, what would become of all the freethinkers, as Max Nordau so pertinently asked recently? Does he cease, and must he cease, on that score to be a Jew? And should he, and need he, therefore, be indifferent to the cries of distress from distant Russia, Roumania or Morocco; or must he,

on that score only, become indifferent to his nation's history, the creations of his great men?

You have decreed that the future of your race is indissolubly connected with this land and that it depends upon the faithful observance of his religion, and your vision shows you "a people of your faith, a great host of Jews in faith," etc. etc., and you behold even "the third and fourth generations clinging so tenaciously to their faith," etc., etc., all of which is not even a plausible or even a possible dream, knowing, as we all do, that the very first generation of the immigrant offspring is already quite indifferent about his religion; even those who, in most cases, have grown up under the guidance of parents who strove to implant religion in them. And yet you expect, through their piety and devotion to save Judaism in this land and to perpetuate your race as a separate entity!

There were days—none can deny the fact — when the Jew’s religion did save him from oblivion, from being dissolved in the caldron of persecution or the paradise of “benevolent assimilation,” but these were the days of strict orthodoxy, of uncompromising devotion to all the “shackles, the peculiarities and the prejudices” which the rabbis and time and custom have fastened upon him. But if your and my descendants will, as your vision reveals to you, discard all these shackles, all the peculiarities and the prejudices which constitute the meat and essence of the Jew’s existence, but will substitute in their place something nebulous and abstract, at the same time eliminating all hope for a future national existence, how will he become “the true and faithful Jew and standard bearer of our religiou,” as you are so singularly privileged to behold in your “vision ?”

Again, if our philanthropists are sincerely desirous of perpetuating the existence of their co-religionists as a separate entity, then it is not through "scattering them over all the length and breadth of this land" to seek better homes in the great and attractive territory which stretches from the Gulf to our northern boundary, from the Mississippi to the Pacific, that you will accomplish your unselfish aim; but by herding them together and confining