he infers that Zionism, representing a migration scheme, has nothing to offer in that direction.
Zionism is not a migration scheme in the sense in which the term is commonly used, nor is it an effort to provide a temporary home of refuge for the persecuted in Russia. It aims to solve the problem of the Jewish race by the acceleration of Jewish self-consciousness. Of course, when this self-consciousness is developed, when the preliminary work of our movement has plowed the way for free access to Palestine, with the guarantees for a free, autonomous State, the persecuted will, most likely, be in the first ranks of the returning exiles. Persecution is only the ever-present shadow accompanying the fact of the existence of the Jew.
X. Zionism retards the perfect Americanization of recent Jewish immigrants, whose success and happiness depend upon their absorption, apart from their faith, into the American people.
Perfect Americanization should be defined. With some Americans, perfect Americanization means intermarriage and a State religion. With some Jews, perfect Americanization means a complete negation of the historical and natural evolution of Jewry. If Americanization means forgetting Jewry, and the throwing overboard of the historical values of our people, then we are glad of the fact that Zionism retards it. But if Americanization means the consciousness of one's own immediate interests, as far as they are interwoven with the political and industrial life of this country, then Zionism does undoubtedly help the newcomer to understand that his value as a citizen depends upon the consciousness of his Jewish
affiliation, and of the fact that he is entitled and in duty bound to become a free citizen, who is able and willing to assert his individuality. We are sorry that there is not enough effort made to inform newcomers of the actual character of American ideals and institutions. Zionism means to produce a stronger individual Jew, a self-assertive man, and not one who is passively submissive under wrong, even in the state of alleged freedom, and this also is the aim of democracy in America. That man who is willing to abdicate all that the past has done to make him, can be neither a Zionist nor a free American citizen.
Mr. Schiff’s letter seems to be a complete defense of the status quo of the Jewish people. Twelve million people cannot be transported to any one geographical centre; therefore, a solution that includes the entire Jewish race is impossible, and consequently each group must shift for itself. Statistics will show that of the twelve million Jews, about ten million live in a state of persecution and oppression. Probably Mr. Schiff speaks in the name of the favored two million.
The dilemma that confronts Mr. Schiff is the alternative of accepting the theory of complete assimilation, or that of strict orthodoxy. But Mr. Schiff does not believe in complete assimilation and proclaims himself a Jew. And the adoption of strict orthodoxy means a return to the Ghetto policy of building a wall about the Hebrew Law, which will create a spiritual separation even worse than the physical separateness advocated by Zionism. Mr. Schiff virtually disclaimed orthodoxy in his Chautauqua address.