SOKOLOW ON FISHBERG'S STATISTICS
From DIE WELT.
DR. FISHBERG may, perhaps, be right. Among the 2,000,000 American Jews there are hardly 12,000, nay, 10,000, and, for all I care, 6,000 shekel-payers. And what's more, not all of the shekel-payers are adult and bona-fide Zionists. Dr. Fishberg, himself and aboriginal American, was often approached and asked to pay a shekel, despite the fact that it should have been well known in Zionist circles that the ancestors of this genuine and aboriginal Yankee landed in America with Columbus. This goes to show that you can't put too much confidence in the Zionist list of shekel-payers. The statistics at best should stand as follows: 12,000 Zionists, 1,288,000 anti-Zionists. Mr. Schiff, you may sleep in peace!
I do not know whether this statistical balm will be of very much help in allaying Mr. ‘Schiff’s fears. I rather suspect that Mr. Schiff regards the matter with more depth than does that expert statistician, Dr. Fishberg. The röles are here transposed. The financial magnate who ought to be expected to regard everything from the point of view of numbers, recognizes in the streams and currents of public opinion, in the fine sentiments of the national soul, the signs of a change, the forerunners of the victorious triumph of a new spirit, and thinks it necessary to array himself against this spirit with the weapons of his opinions and arguments. Dr. Fishberg, however, appears on the scene with pencil in hand, shakes the Zionist purse, counts even the nickles and dimes, estimates their value according to the latest quotations on ‘Change,’ examines inventory and ledger like 3 public accountant, strikes a balance like an expert bookkeeper, and behold! it isn’t worth the trouble to fight Zionism.
He asks, like a true American: "How much is he worth?" And since the sum is ridiculously small, he turns his back upon such a "beggar" like a proud Croesus. Another exchange of rôles with Mr. Schiff. What Mr. Schiff should do, Dr. Fishberg does; what
Dr. Fishberg should do, Mr. Schiff does. What a topsy-turvy world!
I had to laugh when I read a letter in the Hazman in which this polemic was treated in a terribly tragic fashion, together with the days discoveries. America rediscovered ! Where is Zionism? Only 12,000—10,000— 6,000 shekels! If the sensitively disposed reporter of this system of calculation were to go to Berditschew, Krakau, Brody, Budapest, etc, he will be securely armed and will be immune against the bulk of the disclosures of the little Fishbergs.. From every notice, from every protocol of the smallest Zionist society, the same thing could be learned. In the open debates on Nationalism, Assimilation, Socialism, etc., which are held in any and every Shynyppyschok, the discussion is carried on on a much higher plane In Schnyppyschok, too, this numerical proportion of shekels to the Jewish population could be brought forth as a cannon in the field, were it not that the debating schoolboys might find it too childish. But when this thing is American, it becomes a discovery, an event, a sensation. I knew, in Poland, a little Jewish sausage-maker. He was poor and had to emigrate to America. His sausages are just as good or just as bad as they were in Poland, but now he is a “general dealer” (in his little home town they think he has become a general in America), revels in placards, and his picture adorns the advertising columns of the newspapers. This is accomplished by the monster type, high-sounding words, by tricks, by “bluff.” Did we need a disclosure to learn how many shekel-players there are in America? It has been rehearsed thousands of times and every child ought to know it. But in America it needs to be advertised that a stork has a long beak. It merely must be adequately adorned, puffed up, printed in suitable type with as many headlines as possible, and reproduced and heralded in soo-yard-long newspapers. Only then will the reader learn