THE MACCABAEAN
Published once every month by the Maccabaean Publishing Company, of which M. B. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Secretary; whose address is 547 Broadway, New York City. Edited by Louis Lipsky.
JANUARY, 1908
We extend our greetings to "Mathias Acher," who is now in America. We hope that his services to our cause will redound to his credit, as well as in the progress of the movement. Dr. Birnbaum is an eloquent speaker, an acute thinker, and a man who is fully competent to extend the interest in Zionism among thoughtful men and woman
ON Saturday, January 18, and the days following, the New Year for Trees, will be observed by all Zionist societies in America. The collections to be made on these days will be devoted to the Olive Tree Fund. This new holiday on the Zionist calendar is the creation of the Committee of Five of New York, which, in conjunction with the Zionist Council of Greater New York, has arranged for a series of meetings to be held in New York City. It is the aim of the committee to lay out a series of holiday celebrations in which all Zionists shall participate, and which shall become a means of uniting the various societies in a common work at stated intervals. It is hoped that all Zionists will join in making the New Year for Trees an enthusiastic holiday, which shall be uniformly observed among the Jewish people. Remember the Olive Tree Fund!
It is needless to explain that our criticism of Sholom Asch's "El Neckomos" was not intended as a condemnation of his work as a story-writer. In this issue Mr. Berman writes, with a great deal of enthusiasm, of the beauty of style and the simplicity of subject employed by Asch in his sketches. With what Mr. Berman says on that poiint we are in full accord. We wish to say, however, that Asch as a dramatist has been praised, with some qualilcations, by J. L. Peretz, who seems to take special pains to point out that he considers the second act of "El Neckomos" as the work of a genius. The decadent touches of
"El Neckomos" are not observed by this great Yiddish writer. While we criticised the play, we need not assure our readers that we hope the third play Asch has written will prove a genuine Jewish work.
DR. PASMANIK'S ESSAY ON CHARTERS.
WE conclude this month the highly interesting and pertinent essay by Dr. Pasmanik on "Charters and Concessions," and hope that his discussion of this important problem in the movement will have the effect of clearing up misconceptions and pointing the way to a policy that shall be constructive, and shall avoid the common errors of the first years of Zionism. On the question of a charter, he points out that the difference between the charterists and the so-called practical Zionists is merely one of tactics, the content, rather than the form, of advance. It is clear to all observing Zionists that the movement "from above" must give way to the movement which gains its strength, its force, its value, from the masses; and that a policy of action is desirable that will utilize not merely the activities of zealous leaders, but also the rank and file of Zionists, whose own lives must be reconstructed before a charter or a concession will be of any value. With an educated following, with a self-conscious organization, it will be possible to stand rebuffs without flinching, to swerve to the right or left, when necessary, and to march forward with discipline when the way is cleared. With the idea of help "from above," the movement is bound to languish, its adherents are bound to lose interest, and little of any value will be created until the final coup, which, it is expected, will give us the State in Zion. But with the idea of self-emancipation, self-education, self-interest firmly planted among the Jewish people, every advance is permanent, every victory stays won, every hope remains bright until the final consummation.
We believe that Dr. Pasmanik's essay deserves a place in Zionist literature with Pinsker's "Auto-Emancipation" and Herzl's "Jewish State," and we wish to thank Dr. Levenberg, of Cleveland, for his kindness in translating the pamphlet for us.
