THE PRAGMATIC VALUE OF ZIONISM
By PROFESSOR C. PESSELS.
Wırnın the last few years a new school of philosophy has attracted wide attention, and has its workers and disciples in the oldest English university, Oxford, and the most recent American university, Chicago, while Professor James has become the genial expositor of this new instrument of knowledge to an inquiring world. The name of this philosophy is pragmatism, derived from the Greek word pragma, meaning action, and related to our words practical and practise. It values ideas by their consequences. As Professor James bluntly puts it, “Pragmatism seeks to learn the cash value of an idea.” In so far as a thought has power to influence life and conduct, it has value. and 'bevond that it is worthless.
It may be of some profit to consider Zionism from the point of view of this pragmatic philosophy, to consider 'its-cash, value .asea factor in the world of action and of ideas. And for us who are laboring day by day in our homes, and year by year in larger gatherings, for its success, it is very important that we should know the why and wherefore of the energy and time we give to the advancement of this movement.
When I say we should appraise the cash value of Zionism, I shall not be misunderstood as suggesting a sordidly commercial attitude. I disclaim any intention of considering how Zionism may put one dollar in your pockets. But we who are laboring for this cause have a right, nay, it is our duty, to ask ourselves to what end? To carry water in a sieve, to emulate the labors of Sisyphus, are not tasks to engage the energy and enthusiasm of a serious and practical people.
I shall not consider in this paper the large and fascinating question of Zionism as affecting the race as a whole, or try to forecast the reasonable expectations that should follow from a proud and ancient people re-entering its historic home and possessing itself again of the heritage of its fathers. The theme is too large for my small capacity, and has, moreover, received adequate treatment by
other hands. I wish to consider the small but no less vital question of what Zionism is worth to you and me, and what its functions in our lives considered under the twofold aspect of thought and action.
In all the higher processes of the life of the individual, thought precedes action and directs it, as the commander directs the troops under him; and since a commander without an army is but a useless encumbrance upon the resources of the State, so a thought that does not discharge itself in action is equally an encumbrance upon the well-being of the individual, and represents so much psychic waste.
I do not mean that all thought must find its end in what the world calls work. While I should certainly insist upon material and tangible results, I should more strenuously require that thought should react upon the spiritual and intangible forces of conduct and character, and touch the soul to finer issues.
To put the matter concretely, what change has Zionism brought in your life? To the extent that it has engaged your interest and influenced your outlook upon the world, it is a living force for you; beyond that it is nothing, or worse than nothing. The payment of shekolim and dues to your collector does not make you a Zionist any more than giving a nickel to an importunate beggar makes you a philanthropist. Unless you actually work for its success, it has no real significance for you. If you look at it as a new scheme to colonizePalestine with the homeless and downtrodden Jews of Eastern Europe, as a philanthropicenterprise for the relief of misery and distress, your sympathies will be rightly enlisted’ and your services engaged in so far as the plan appeals to your kindness of heart, to the tenderness "of your sensibilities.. And when we are gravely-told that three-fourths of the Jews are on the verge of starvation, you are presented with a situation that demands the best of your energies to ameliorate so terrible a plight.
But Zionism is much more than a philan-