The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 4 · April 1908
163printed page
scan 31 of 38

COMMUNICATIONS

THE KNIGHTS OF ZION.

To THE MACCABAEAN:

I noticed your answer to Miss A. G. regarding the Order Knights of Zion, that the order is not antagonistic to the federation. Allow me to say something in this behalf. The friction that generally takes place between the Knights of Zion and the Federation is due to the facts that they are always classed as two organizations, when in fact there is only one organization, and that is the Federation of American Zionists, an organization that is recognized by the Actions Committee and by the Congress, while the Knights of Zion is an organization that practically has less members than any council that belongs to the Federation; and allow me to correct you that the Order does not belong to the Federation. Though Zionists, they ought to be affiliated with the Federation, and for the last two years the Order did not pay any per capita tax to the Federation, and before that time they always made settlements with the Federation.

Now, what is the Order Knights of Zion? Zionistic or not, allow me to say that in name they are, but in practice they are not. Let us take for example the Zionist institutions, how they are cared for by the Order. We know that the Zionists have to support the Actions Committee in their work, and the first thing a Zionist society ought to do is to see that its organized members should pay its shekolim, a nominal sum of twenty-five cents, which everybody can afford, but what do we see? In the year of 1904-5, when they claimed a membership of over 3,000, shekolim were paid for only 800 members. In the year of 1905-6, thanks to the cleverness of Dr. Magnes, he was successful in getting 1,200 shekolim, and a balance of nearly as much is stil due. This year, I mean the year of 1906-7, they printed their own shekolim, which in itself was illegal, and have sold shekolim to people that are members of no organization, and altogether their shekolim forwarded to the small Actions Committee through the office of the Federation numbered only one hundred and eight dollars and cents, which means four

hundred and thirty-five shekolim, for members. and no members. The Actions Committee could have done a lot of work if all would have followed the example of that so-called Zionist organization, that claims the right of representing ten middle western states!

Now let us take the Federation; it only gets twenty-five cents a year per capita, and I presume that some pay still less, while the Order gets fifty cents per capita, besides the shekel, and we see that the Federation for wards a shekel for each member, and thousands of shekolim besides, and the cities that belong to the Order until about two years ago and now when they join the Federation, which it is still farther for them from Chicago, and we find that, for instance, St. Louis itself not having other towns like the Order has, gave more shekolim this year than the Order ever gave in its best years, when it claimed eighty-two gates, or Louisville contributes more to Zionist institutions than the Order with its subordinate gates combined. I think that THE MACCABAEAN, as a Zionist organ, is in duty bound not only to write instructive articles about Zionism, but to look into the work of the societies and call attention to certain inactive places, show the fault of negligence, criticize certain societies, and the movement would gain a lot by it. It would strengthen our forces; it would do away with petty politics, when there is an Order in Chicago that claims to be Zionistic and is against the fundamental principles of the Zionist organization, never gave a helping hand to the Federation and hardly ever contributed towards Zionistic institutions, then it is the duty of our organ to reproach them for not fulfilling their duties, and then it is the duty of the Federation to see that a city like Chicago shall have a proper organization and force out the old detrimental system, and that a sincere man, no politician, be put on the head of it, for proper men, no politicians, could have made Chicago a real Zionist center.

JULIUS KATZOF.

To THE MACCABAEAN:

In my last correspondence I wrote to you that THE MACCABAEAN as an organ ought to