The Maccabaean · Vol. XIV, No. 6 · June 1908
240printed page
scan 30 of 42

and eager, to make present sacrifices for the future. Had Herzl succeeded in acquiring territorial concessions from Turkey, there would still have remained the work of education among the Jewish masses before we could have had the material for the upbuilding of the nation.

The organization of an order which recognizes, at the same time as it pledges its devotion to Zionism, the actual relations of men, which seeks to unite the Jews in bonds of their immediate requirements, and builds all this upon the Zionist hope, indeed shows that the ideal of our movement is an abiding one, and that we shall have in the order a band of men upon whom we can depend for steady loyalty and generous support.

By its system of degrees, it will also be in a position to honor those workers in the movement whose exceptional zeal has been of benefit in the promotion of our aim. We now have a band of veterans who, in time, seem to lose official connection with the movement and who receive no official recognition. "The Golden Book entries do not indicate with any degree of accuracy the quality of our workers. In many instances the entry of a man there means nothing more than the good-humored generosity of the donors. The order, however, will from time to time confer its honorary degrees upon those who have actually served the cause and who have not been adequately appreciated.

While the order has not received and has not asked for the official recognition of the Federation, it is but proper that due credit should be given to the originators of the movement. The hope may be expressed, however, that the bases of its financial features be carefully devised, and that all precautions be taken to prevent miscalculations as to the scope of its benefit and insurance clauses.

THE CASE OF MISS RICHMAHN.

THE American Hebrew, after precipitating a communal scandal, diplomatically retires from the scene of battle, and cautions hotheaded critics and petitioners against doing anything rash. With the propriety of this method of journalistic warfare we have nothing to do. We are curious to know, of course,

what motive prompted the first attack upon Miss Julia Richman, the defendant in the case, and why, after the community had received what might be taken as ofhcial consent to begin an attack, a volte face should be executed admonishing the usual course of silence and discretion. But our curiosity must be smothered, for the time being, for what interests us is the principle involved in the criticism of a member of the Jewish people who occupies a civic position. What is the rule which should guide the Jewish citizen when a representative Jew proves guilty of the crime of slander of the Tewish neonle ?

Miss Julia Richman is a teacher in the service of the City of New York. She has been connected with the public school system for over a quarter of a century. She is recognized by the authorities as an able, competent and energetic pedagogue. At the same time she is a director of the Educational Alliance, of which Dr. David Blaustein was formerly superintendent, and which is supported by Jews. At a meeting recently held in New York City Miss Richman, in reply to the Commissioner of Police, who was pleading for gentler treatment of the pushcart peddlers, is reported to have said, in substance, that, if the pushcart peddlers would not obey the city ordinances, they ought to go back where they came from. For this remark Miss Richman has been criticised, and, after it had been repeated in amplified form many times, in connection with more alleged treasonable remarks about the Jewish people, has been made the basis of a petition calling for her transference from a Jewish neighborhood.

Upon what principle did the American Hebrew act when it cautioned Miss Richman to be silent? It was upon the old principle of communal silence. It was admitted that the pushcart peddiers had violated the city ordinance; that they had refused to abide by the rules governing highways, but Miss Richman had, in a moment of American patriotism, spoke as the ordinary American patriot usually speaks. She had forgotten the rules of the diplomatic game. She had spoken the truth; but, according to Jewish diplomacy, the truth is only that which can be printed in the American Hebrew, and, inasmuch as that organ had not spoken on the subject, Miss Rich-