The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 2 · August 1908
65printed page
scan 29 of 64
Facsimile · scan 29 of 64
Scan of p. 65
Text · transcribed from the scan

knows us to be, and what, by every right and title of ancestry and inheritance, we shall and must be—a separate people, the Jewish nation. And all because of the fear of mah yomru hagoyim, what the Goyim will say. For that reason and that only have many of our treasured heirlooms been thrown away or destroyed. For that reason, have ingenious theories been developed, beautiful card houses been built, whose only fault lies in the fact that they are false. It is that Ghetto spirit ı1f fear which preaches that the Jew must separate himself from the community only in the synagogue. It is that Ghetto spirit which harps on the Americanization of our immigrants as though Americanizing were only a znatter of the style of clothes, of speaking American slang and of throwing off Jewish customs. It is that Ghetto spirit which has made our Jewish institutions call themselves non-sectarian and become un-Jewish. It is that Ghetto spirit of dread which teaches that all that is distinctive and conducive to the perpetuation of our separateness must be discarded, and tries to delude the world into the belief that Judaism consists only of a few conveniently selected metaphysical and universalistic dogmas. We are happy that Zionism is free from this Ghetto spirit, and we have no fear to -be Jews in faith and in all else, to be whole Jews, feeling no need to apologize to anyone for what we are, for our position, for our efforts, our desires and our hopes. It was .only when the old and groundless charge was made impugning our loyalty to this country, that our Federation was obliged for the sake of truth to enter a vigorous protest and denial. We shall never permit this charge, whether in this form or in any other, whether casting doubt upon our patriotism, our loyalty, or our good citizenship, to pass without publicly denouncing it as unfounded, untrue and un-American, it matters not by whom made, whether by anti-Zionist or by anti-Semite.

This land demands our complete loyalty

and devotion, our highest efforts for its advancement in material prosperity, in culture and in morals. But it does not demand that we shall be recreant to any duty, whether it be to our family, to our kin, to our people, here or elsewhere.

No true Christian has ever questioned our right to be true Jews, not fractional Jews, but complete Jews, proud of a common and glorious past, striving for a common and glorious future. But I can already hear our opponents who are skilled in the use of well-sounding phrases and who can cover up a vast emptiness and barrenness with euphemisms, such as "occidental" and "modernism" and "Americanization of immigrants," at least in the second and third generations," I hear them say that they too believe in being complete Jews. When I speak of fractional Jews, I am referring to the Yom Kippur Jews, to the club Jews, to the Kaddish Jews and the like. And so I must explain more definitely what we mean by a whole Jew. We mean the Jew who, in his entire life as well as in the synagogue, lives a Jewish life, who feels himself a part of our people wherever scattered, whatever their stage of culture, whatever their religious belief or its expression, who feels sympathy with oppressed Jews because they are his brethren and not simply on humanitarian grounds, who feels that his own future and the future of his children's children are indissolubly bound up in that of his brethren; that not only in calamity but in peace and prosperity, they are one; who is not obliged out of fear, out of avdus besoch cherus to celebrate Tishi b'Ab as a feast day; a Jew adorned by every Jewish virtue,—such a one we call a whole Jew.

And as Zionism in its ultimate fulfilment will remove the shackles of the centuries, give back a normal life to the Jewish people, free the Jewish spirit from its long thraldom, so the Zionist in his striving for it finds now the possibility of becoming free and whole.