The Maccabaean · Vol. XV, No. 4 · October 1908
154printed page
scan 10 of 42

standard below the rate of subsistence of the Arab!

Think of the Arab who possesses a patch of arable soil with a garden and sometimes a wineyard of his own and of the Jew who is wholly dependent upon the wages he receives for his toil—think of them both and you will see that in respect to labor cheapness the Arab is far above the Jew. And the difference in physical strength between the Arab and the Jew! I cannot admit even for a moment that the Jew will have the upper hand in such a desperate strife.

The fact is that the Jew is more highly paid and better treated than the Arab even now. Our workingmen penetrate into the Jewish colonies and industrial enterprises not because they demand less than the Arabs but, on the contrary, because they are more available, on account of their skill and abilities. Those colonists who comprehend the requirements of production employ Jewish laborers. The facts of Palestinian life corroborate once more the economic truth outlined above.

Of course, the enthusiasm which the advocates of sacrifice call for is not to be underrated. And all I have said does not in the least tend to undermine the loftiness and usefulness of fervent idealism on the part of the Zionists.

In addition, idealism is very practicable for those inspired by it. While he who goes to Palestine for mere personal purposes stumbles on the first obstacle and leaves that land with an embittered heart against the whole world, the Zionist who goes to Palestine with the object of remaining there by all means may more easily adapt himself to the new environment, and, as a rule, he soon finds a favorable fortune where the impatient fortune-seeker sees hindrazces not to be overcome. This kind of usefulness of enthusiasm for the enthusiasts themselves and the people is not to be denied or even underestimated. The largeı the number of such idealists in the Zionist movement the better.

But who will assert that idealism means the reduction of the standard of living? Self-forgetting idealism is highly valuable for Zionism. But it might be availed of where necessary. It is dangerous when used as an

economic factor in competition with the Arabs or in the development of our settlement in Palestine on the whole. Have we the possibility to exert a considerable influence upon what is being done in Palestine in order to solve the national labor question? Evidently, the very fact that the Zionist movemeint does exist proves that we have a mission to fulfill. That is, we are called upon to contribute to the, so to say, mechanical processes of social life which necessitate the re-establishment of our national freedom. Much can be done and should be done by systematic efforts

Dr. Herzl did not fail to provide us with a valuable method, which might be employed by the Zionist movement in the case I am discussing. In his "Judenstaat," Herzl proposed a Jewish company, which is now replaced to a certain degree by our Colonial Bank, which would have to deal with the colonization of Palestine as well as with the regulation of the Jewish emigration from the Golus. In Herzl's opinion the Company should have been charged with the particular task of establishing a seven-hour labor day and providing the Jewish workingmen with sanitary conditions of life and labor. One of the paramount maxims of the Company should have been the employment of more Jewish laborers not only in the enterprises undertaken by the Company as such, but also everywhere the Company's influence might be exercised. "It may happen," says Herzl, "that a certain undertaker would desire to employ labor from without, but the question is, whether he would succeed. By dint of boycott of such manufacturers and by other measures the Jewish Company would endeavor to prevent the importation of non-Jewish workingmen into the country so that it should be necessary to employ the seven-hour laborers." Such is the method devised by Herzl who wonderfully embraced nearly all Zionist questions in their full purport and bearing upon the destinies of the Jewish life in Palestine. It is indeed a sound principle.

Our financial institutions insofar as they extend their support to various private corporations or single enterpreneurs or undertakers should insist upon the employment of