THE MACCABAEAN
Published once every month by the Maccabaean Publishing Company, of which M. B. Lande is President; and D. H. Lieberman is Treasurer; whose address is 547 Broadway, New York City.
THE KNIGHTS OF ZION.
THE action of the Zionist administration in granting a charter to the Order Knights of Zion, places the Federation of American Zionists in a delicate position. It has no desire to enter into a controversy with the Knights. It has had too much to do with that organization during the past few years. It has aimed to treat with the Knights as an honorable, responsible body, but in every instance it has met with duplicity or irresponsibility on the part of those who speak for that body.
But the Actions Comite brings the matter up again, after we had already dismissed the subject from our thoughts. We had decided to have absolutely nothing whatever to do with an organization with which we could not enter into honorable and responsible agreements for co-operation. The hasty action of President Wolffsohn and his advisers places us now in the position of great embarrassment.
It is unnecessary to point out that merely granting recognition to the Knights, without fixing its jurisdiction, introduces matter which may cause friction of a serious nature; but we allude to this as evidence of the thoughtlessness of the Actions Comite, to which their attention must be called.
The primary objections to the issuance of a charter as a Federation to the Knights are legal ones. According to the statutes of the Congress, the power rests with the Actions Comite to recognize any group, which shall pay into the treasury of the Comite the shekel payments of three thousand Zionists, provided there is no other Federation in existence in the same territory; and if there is, then the consent of that Federation must first be obtained, although the consent of the prior Federation is not a condition prece-
dent to official recognition. The object of such a procedure is obvious. It aims at providing the Actions Comite with the information necessary in coming to a decision. The Actions Comite was supposed to ascertain local conditions, and then act according to its best judgment.
First, The Order Knights of Zion has not paid into the treasury of the administration a sum representing the shekel payments of three thousand Zionists. The sum sent in is only about sixty-five per cent. of the required payment.
Second, It does not appear that the payment represents shekel-money, and for all we know, or the Actions Comite might know, it may be the donation of a private individual, who wishes to see a new federation established.
Third, The consent of the American Federation was not asked for, and no adequate notice was given to it in order that it might enter a protest, and give its reasons against the proposition.
The secondary objections, which are probably weightier than the legal ones, are based on the advisability of creating two federations in the United States.
First, The creation of another federation in the United States will do harm to our Zionist propaganda. Americans are used to dealing with an idea presented by one body. They do not feel secure in giving consideration to an idea when a variety of organizations present it. The United States is one, the Zionist movement here ought to be represented by one body. Whatever system of co-ordination we might establish, the world at large should know of only one body. To have the Knights in the West, the American Federation in the East, does not mean that either remains in its own locality. The American Jewish people will consider both in the light of rivals, and rivalry in Zionism is not desirable or beneficial.
Second, The Knights of Zion has not shown that it is competent to undertake any sort of propaganda for Zionism in the West.
Third, The Federation of American Zionists is amply competent to cover the United States, East and West. If it has not developed