The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
12printed page
scan 13 of 50

THE AMERICAN JEWISH COMMITTEE

A Review of its Annual Report

Two months ago the American Jewish Committee held its second annual meeting in New York City. Only the members of that body were admitted at the proceedings. The press was not admitted, but had to be content with a very carefully prepared statement issued by the secretary, of the substance of the proceedings. Fortunately, the committee has now issued a report of the proceedings of that eventful day. It is a little booklet. It contains chiefly "The Report of the Executive Committee to the members of the American Jewish Committee," the reading of which was apparently the most important part of the proceedings. Why this report can now be spread broadcast in a booklet, while two months ago, not even newspapermen could listen to it, is one of those delicate question which only a Jewish diplomat can solve.

There is nothing in it which is unfit for the ears of reporters. In fact, in a way, it is a very interesting little book. It treats of matters diplomatic, political, national and international. It tells plainly what the American Jewish Committee has done, with no regard for the importance or significance of the separate matters which have come under its "consideration." It also treats fully of matters with which it has had nothing to do. On the whole, it seems to be a sort of miniature reproduction of the message of an executive to a legislature upon the "state and welfare of the nation." What nation? What body? The body of one million and a half American Jews whom it has appointed itself to represent.

Let us review this report, dividing the

matters which it considers into several classes, political, national, international and miscellaneous. It might perhaps be more edifying to make another classification, such as, what the Committee has accomplished, and what it has not accomplished. But this would involve very difficult questions, as for example, when a committee passes a resolution, has anything been done? The first is good enough. It is fair, and admits of comprehensiveness.

POLITICAL.

"Your Committee is happy to be able to report," says the report, "that during the year, the immigration problem has not been acute from the point of view of Federal legislation." Is happy to be able, sounds almost as if "your Committee" had been some sort of a factor in making the immigration problem "not acute from the point of view of Federal Legislation." But, of course, this is not meant. You and I, as Jews, are happy to be able to state the same thing. Has the Committee done anything exceptional in the interests of unrestricted immigration? It has done something. There is an investigation to be carried on by the United States Immigration Commission. "Proper steps have been taken that in case hearings are held, your Committee will be duly notified." This is obviously at least a necessary action. The Committee would not learn, if hearings are to be held, through the ordinary public channels of information. Like other "diplomatic" bodies, it has to be officially notified before being aware of it.