The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 1 · January 1909
16printed page
scan 16 of 50

ness it is to seize upon even the least interesting news. Tucked away in a corner of the Record, there may be a single remark of some obscure legislator, a remark perhaps never spoken, but simply printed, which may nevertheless affect the whole future existence of Jews in this country. Washington correspondents are notoriously lacking in their sense of importance. A single remark of this nature may require instantaneous attention, long distance telephone calls, deep consideration, carefully prepared statements, action and organization.

The Committee has been putting forth "earnest efforts to put in operation the plan for an Advisory Council in each district." This has not been completed but "substantial progress has been made."

The organization of the N. Y. Kehila was sanctioned after it had been fully organized. The committee itself has not taken steps to advance the cause of democracy in its constitution, aside from “O. K.” ing the spontaneous attempt of the New York community.

Fron a careful reading of the report, it is evident that the American Jewish Committee has succeeded Mr. Simon Wolf in office as the guardian of Jewish interests. But Mr. Wolf was never as careful as the Committee has been during its existence of two years. He was never so diplomatic as to pride himself on having succeeded in maintaining a `statesmanlike

calm, which will not be ruffled by the wind of circumstance. He posed as the unaccredited representative of the Jewish people. The American Jewish Committee, composed of men of large influence, men who are supposed to have a keen interest in Jewish affairs, should. have been able to present a better account of a year’s work. If it had been accomplished nothing, but outlined a policy of action, it might have justified its existence. If it had done nothing, but taken up one issue with vigor, it would have justified its existence. But it has pursued the even tenor of its somnolent way willing to be judged by appeals to activity which it has resisted, rather than by its own original contribution to Jewish affairs, and on that ground the candid observer must report that it has been weighed and found wanting.

It is worth noting that a number of our best Zionists are members of the Committee. Among them are Dr. Harry Friedenwald, Dr. J. L. Magnes, the energetic secretary, Dr. Herbert Friedenwald, Mr. D. H. Lieberman, and others; but it seems that once in the meshes of a goluth-inspired Jewish organization, once having subscribed to the program of the Committee, they can do little effective work in the direction of inspiring a policy which shall be truly national.

S.