The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 3 · March 1909
97printed page
scan 19 of 52

vantage. I assure you it is comparatively easier to alter your foreign name into a simon-pure American name, to subscribe yourself a Unitarian, to forego the pleasure and comforts of Jewish company, than to take up the burden of re-establishing the Jewish nation in Palestine.

It is easier to give way than to resist. It is more comfortable to be in the fashion than to be in a minority. It would be less difficult for the Russian Jews to make terms with Russia by entering the Greek Catholic Church, than to take up arms to resist the evident policy of the Russian government to reduce Jews to slavery. The Spanish Jews who prolonged, for a time, their Jewish traditions as Marranos, could have neglected their Sabbath traditions and their Passover ceremonies, and actually entered into the formal observance of Catholicism.

There are few among the opponents of Zionism who charge us with cowardice. They say Zionism gives up the battle of Jews for recognition in the countries of oppression. We reply it is they who give up the fight; it is they, anti-Zionists, who are giving up, inch by inch, the elements that make the Jewish people distinctive and valuable in the world's civilization. It is they who are throwing overboard, for present ease and comfort, the mission, which they have the impudence to say they represent in goluth. It is they who, out of ignorance, or stupidity, or social or political ambitions, parade before the world as the bearers of light, and who spread the darkness of irreligion and materialism and social ignominy wherever they go.

The Jewish spirit, represented by Zionism, chooses, however, not the materialistic escape, not the escape by way of suicide, by way of ignominy, but the escape by way of sacrifice and resistance and effort. We aim to move our camp to favorable environments, where the mission, of which our sensationalist opponents speak, may have freedom to express itself, if indeed we have a mission in this world, or if it is necessary in order to justify our existence that we actually claim to have a mission. The man who subscribes himself Jew and Zionist,

though the designation Jew makes him liable even in a free country to special disabilities, and the designation of Zionist opens up questions as to his American patriotism, is the braver and the more manly individual.

He desires to live without a denial of the rights of his race or nation, and though his ideals mean temporary disadvantages, though it may mean a temporary withdrawal from the camp of European civilization, he prefers to sacrifice all that that civilization means for the sake of the future of his people.

It is impossible to maintain the Jewish identity in goluth. The Jewish people are numerically weak; the influences of environment and the rule of majorities are so insistent and so unavoidable, that those leaders who counsel the erection of Judaism into a citadel from which the Jewish spirit, shall emerge, strong and normal, are to be likened to the Quixotes, who fight windmills that do not exist, and stumble over stones in their path.

The Jewish religion cannot be converted into a citadel of Jewish life in the goluth. Judaism is the product of a national life. Its post-exilic traditions are inspired with national principles, and guided by the instinct of preserving the national life. Deny the worth and the right of that national life, and the tradition, the religion, has no basis in religious authority. Every prayer you utter is inspired by the thought of a return to national normality. Every hope the orthodox Jew expresses is colored by the longing to return to Palestine. Judaism without Zion loses its cardinal principle. A nation of priests the Jews were supposed to be, and the priests had to discharge their functions in the Temple, the center of national life.

In Austria, a movement is on foot to utilize the conflict of races in that kingdom for the creation of a citadel of normal Jewish life there. Their aim is to establish a federation of nationalities, and in that federation the Jews, concentrated on a definite territory, may be able to perpetuate their racial and national culture and traditions: The movement is, however,