The Maccabaean · Vol. XVI, No. 5 · May 1909
163printed page
scan 11 of 52

The Jews and Their English Patriotism

A Discussion of a Question which now Preplexes English Jewry

A controversy of more than usual interest has arisen in English Jewish circles between men who are graduates of the English universities. Mr. Norman Bentwich, in the course of an interview with the Jewish Chronicle on "Zionism in English Universities" had said that the Zionist students "feel that as Jews, it is not possible to identify themselves completely with the English nation. They cannot be as entirely English in thought as the man who is born of English parents and descended from ancestors who have mingled their blood with other Englishmen for generations. There is no disguising this fact. To me it seems impossible to separate religion from nationality in Judaism."

These statements aroused the ire of a number of "Englishmen of the Jewish persuasion," who wrote the following protest to the Jewish Chronicle:

"I. We deeply deplore the statement that Jews are not, and can never be, 'entirely English in thought.' We object to the distinction made between Jews and persons 'born of English parents.' For we contend that Jews can be, and are, born of English parents, even though their parents are Jews. When an alien has become naturalized, he is an Englishman in his rights and obligations, and we hold that it is his duty to see to it that his children shall grow up, as Jews, 'entirely English in thought'—as English in aspiration, interest and zeal as those who are descended from ancestors who have mingled their blood with other Englishmen for generations.'"

"2. While we may hold different con-

ceptions of Judaism, we all agree in repudiating the suggestion that Judaism does not allow its adherents to become 'entirely English in thought.'

"3. We regard it as dangerous that the rising generation of educated Jews should be encouraged in opinions, which (a) must tend to alienate them from other Englishmen, (b) demolish the structure of the arguments, advanced, for example, by Lord Macaulay, on which the Act for the Removal of Jewish Disabilities was supported, and (c) are likely to arouse some suspicion in all classes of society, and particularly in the working-classes among whom Jewish immigrants have to make their way, as to the measure of patriotism among English Jews.

4. We gladly learn that undergraduatesadhering to the cause advocated by Mr.Norman Bentwich will 'not regard themselves as a nation apart from the Englishpeople,' and that they will be 'preparedto exercise fully their rights and dutiesas English citizens'. But we desire topoint out that these concessions are reallyof no adequate avail. We do not believethat it is logical for persons to claim'rights and duties as English citizenswhen they assert in the same breath tha.they cannot 'completely identify themselveswith the English nation,' and cannot be'entirely English in thought.' We fear thatEnglishmen of other creeds may not beequally confident as to the future ability ofmen trained in these views to 'exercisefully their rights and duties as Englishcitizens,' and thus the apprehensions wehave already expressed become increasingly grave."