THE MACCABAEAN
Published once every month by The Maccabean Publishing Company. M. B. Lande, President; D. H. Lieberman, Treasurer; address for the business of the corporation, 547 Broadway, N. Y.
JUNE, 1909.
CIVIC RIGHTS.
THE MACCABEAN is not a political journal, nor is it part of its business to comment on American political life, but we are quite in line with our principles when we point out the fact, that the Jews of the city of New York are too ignorant of their rights, or too indifferent to them, or too timid about enforcing them, for their own interest.
It is a fact that numerically, the Jews are about one-fourth or one-fifth of the population of Manhattan. They possess more than their share of the middle class business of the city; they are, probably, out of proportion in the number of able men they contribute to the professions. Our Jewish citizens are more alert, more self-sacrificing, more intensely interesting in civic issues, than are their neighbors. This is not said in the spirit of boastfulness, but it is a fact, which is visible to all unbiased observers. To the anti-Semite it is too obvious, and he makes a great deal of it.
At the same time, the Jews are underrepresented in all departmnts of civic service. They have not a proportionate representation in the elective offiees, nor in the appointive offices. Taking into account their extraordinary activity, their lively ambitions, their keener intellectuality, their psychic activity, they should, in an open competition, capture even more than their proportionate number in the field of civic service. But they have less than the Irish, less than the German; in short, they have not, all things considered, their fair share of the advantages offered by the civic government to talent and ability.
It would be folly to say that this is due to avowed prejudice of any sort. It may be due, to a great extent, as was said above, to the indifference, the timidity, the ignorance of the Jews in the ways of politics. But that is a very poor explanation. The better explanation, to our mind, is, that the Jews, by reason of their timidity, their fear of raising a public scandal, their reluctance to test their standing in the community, give power to those who are, for one reason or another, unconsciously or deliberately, afraid of the rising power of the Jews, who are still regarded, unconsciously or consciously, as aliens.
Tammany Hall gets its large vote from Jews, and Tammany is said to be close to the heart of the people, yet if you look over the list of Tammany office-holders you will find that out of all proportion the Irish obtain the offices in the party with which so large a percentage of Jews vote. In the civil service, which is ostensibly open to free competition, the Jews are inadequately represented.
Moreover, in the public school system, in which the Jews are, for the past few years, entering in large numbers, you will not find that Jews, who are credited with ambitions, with a strong desire for advancement, ever reach the higher positions. They are given the subordinate positions where merit counts, but as the salaries rise, it becomes more and more difficult for them to go further. In the entire city of New York, with probably over one thousand Jewish teachers of all grades, there is not more than one Jew who has so far attained to a position that pays more than three thousand dollars per annum.
Your conventional citizen, who loves to mouth platitudes, will tell you that "merit" wins out, and that national or sectional or religious interests ought not to intrude in the domain of American politics. As a matter of fact, however, the municipality of New York is conducted with an eye to appeasing all these elements, and