Palestine Committee that was not offered at the same time against the entire executive. The executive had never taken steps to compel societies to appoint local Palestine Committees. Kaminer also joined in the discussion.
The Convention adopted the following resolution presentd by the executive committee, and in the hands of the delegates in printed form:
"That the Federation establish an information Bureau under the auspices of the Palestine Committee for the purpose of furnishing reliable data in re conditions of settlement in Palestine."
There was a brief discussion on this resolution by Norwalk, Frishberg and Wilson.
The Secretary moved the following resolution presented by the executive committee:
"That until further steps are taken or new institutions created by the Actions Committee, all efforts should be concentrated on the Zionist instituions now existing in Palestine, and that the Zionist societies endeavor to strengthen the sentiment favorable to these institutions."
Miss Szold pointed out that the resolution contained a number of redundancies. The resolution was ordered turned over to the resolutions committee for re-statement.
Goldman, for the Dorshei Zion of St. Louis presented the following resolution :
"That it is advisable to establish Palestine Land Development companies in the United States, which shall issue stock at the minimum value of $100.00, payable at the rate of ten dollars per annum.
‘That it is the duty of every Zionist to purchase at least one share in such a company.
“That a special Land Development Committee be established, : which shall nave charge of the organization and encouragement of these companies.”
De Haas said that the question introduced by Goldman involved the first principles of policy. He favored an open discussion on the principles involved.
Goldman was given the floor to explain what he intended to have the Convention
endorse. He spoke of the necessity of practical work in Palestine, and insisted that every opportunity to invest in land in Erez Israel should be grasped.
Aronson (guest) spoke of the work of the Palestine Land Development Company. It appeared that Goldman's companies were not, in a strict sense, land development companies as the term is used in Zionist circles.
Lipsky moved to refer Goldman's resolution to the incoming executive committee. He pointed out that the convention was not competent to endorse a plan that involved so many details.
Goldman protested against his motion being referred to the executive. Magnes favored an open discussion. The discussion then proceeded on the motion to refer and on the main question. The debators were: Norwalk, Maltin, Frankel, Rosenthal, Fishlowitz, Kaminer, Teitler, Deitsch, Hurwitz, Caplan.
The sentiment seemed to be favorable to Goldman's scheme. The opposition to it seemed to be based on the principle that the Federation, as such, should not assume responsibility for the organization of such enterprises, and that the matters of detail could best be left to the organizations themselves. Frankel pointed out that the movement needs, not only enterprises that shall appeal to national sentiments, but also enterprises in which the individual shall have a personal interest.
Jasin said that the resolution that had been referred to the resolution committee for re-statement covered the ground of Goldman's resolution, and if the former resolution were considered first, Goldman's resolution would stand out more clearer.
De Haas moved a substitute for the resolution moved by Jasin and Goldman's resolution. The de Haas resolution read as follows:
"That it is the opinion of this Convention that the Action Committee shall concentrate all its efforts upon the direct work and existing institutions of the movement; that it shall not engage upon the founding of new financial bodies, nor shall it thrust upon the various Zionist bodies responsibil-