The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 3 · September 1909
88printed page
scan 2 of 52

are bound to depend upon the different national groups in the empire. They are bound to heed the desires of these groups. They will find that an appeal to Ottoman patriotism must be coupled with a recognition of the territorial rights of groups, who have, by reason of concentration on one area and historic settlement, established their claims to recognition by the central government.

To gain the sympathy of the Arabs, the Armenians, the Kurds, the Syrians, it will be necessary to concede local autonomy to each of them. Already the rumbling of dissensions is heard, and among the Cretans and the Bulgarians, there is now a premonition of what will occur elsewhere, should the policy of concentration be continued. Without Europe, the Young Turks must concede rights to the national groups. And the Young Turks assert over and over again that Europe must keep its hands off.

The Young Turks are, therefore, heading for the rocks of disaster by arrogant demands for their unqualified and unquestioned leadership in the affairs of the empire. They are paving the way for a widespread civil war by their obstinate chauvinistic proclamations. The more they insist upon it, the stronger becomes the reaction, and at the same time, the more violent becomes the antagonism of the various national groups. It is true, a strong central government is essential to the integrity of the Turkish Empire, but if the Young Turks are as good statesmen as they are soldiers, they will see that the business of the hour is the conciliation of the disaffected groups.

The present Young Turks have three enemies lurking in the various corners of the empire: the reactionaries, friends of the old regime; the various national groups, still held in check by fears of European interferences; and those enlightened Young Turks, who believe in the integrity of the empire, and in the necessity of conciliating the various national groups by granting them a share in the government. Nor is the danger of an Armenian uprising to be discounted. Whenever the Arabs shall have acquired skill in European warfare and their own unity, the Turks may well tremble for their empire. Should the Young Turks now in control remain the chauvinists they seem to be, then Turkey will certainly witness another upheaval within a short time and the only question will be, which of the three or four parties enumerated will wrest the control away from the Young Turks.

We Zionists are greatly interested in the outcome, naturally. Our admiration for the skill and the strength of the Young Turks remains unabated; at the same time, without dwelling on our own interests in the matter, and wishing for the maintenance of an independent, and strong Turkish Empire, under constitutional guarantees, our hope is, that the Young Turks themselves will be persuaded, before disaster overwhelms them, to favor the policy of granting such territorial rights to national or race groups, that will, while giving away local power, retain to a representative government all the necessary powers to become strong and effective.