THE MACCABAEAN
ZIONISM AND JEWISH IDEALS
By LAURIE MAGNUS.
From an address delivered by Mr. Magnus, at the Birmingham (England) Young Men's Hebrew Association, on Sunday, October 10th. The views therein contained present the peculiar position occupied by one who is considered an authority in certain literary circles, and who asserts that he is indeed a Zionist, but with new views. In order to present Mr. Magnus's views, which are in their way of interest, and at the same time have our readers avoid the mistake of overlooking a number of strange inconsistencies, we append the discussion of Mr. Israel Cohen, the well-known Zionist writer.
In attempting to write a paper on any topic of general interest, it is well to try at the beginning to determine some common boundaries. With this object, I have set myself to discover what is precisely what I mean by the word and conception of Zionism. What does Zionism stand for in my life? Does it supply a material need? Does it fulfil a spiritual longing? Does it rest on an intellectual foundation? What is Zion to me and what am I to Zion that I should weep or work for her?
I think I shall command universal consent when I say that Judaism without Zionism is an empty and a barren creed. If I am a Jew in anything more than a merely racial sense, I am ex hypothesi a Zionist. So far, I may take it that we are agreed. There is no vital Judaism which does not contain Zionism.
But the Zionism of this belief, which is
essential to my activity as a Jew, must be in accordance with—it must arise out of—traditional Jewish idealism. By as much as it departs from that tradition, constantly modified though this may be by historical experience, it will appeal to a different set of feelings, and will express itself in modes other than, even if not necessarily alien to, Jewish ideals as such. And by as much as it departs from Jewish ideals, or colors those ideals with borrowed lights, it will disturb the tradition which I cherish, and will increase the stature of what would seem the full-grown perplexity of belief. And anything which makes faith more difficult, instead of simplifying it, in the present age, anything which further involves the spirit of the religious life in the clinging integuments of controversy, may fairly be required to establish its credentials, and to justify its claim as a part of the materia theologica—of the texture of religious belief.
I aim at Zion, as a Jew, in a very real and a very necessary sense. There is no fibre of my Jewish consciousness which does not thrill to the prayer for the Restoration. The iron resolution of the Prophets has entered into my soul, and the glory of their speech tinges my imagination with splendor. One does not commonly talk of these things, nor lay bare to the scapel of logic the immaterial fabric of faith. But the strength of Zion is beyond fear. Though her walls lie in ruins, they are raised supreme above attack. The logic of facts is powerless against the