The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
196printed page
scan 14 of 52

thank God I forget about it.......You read a good many newspapers; tell me the news."

“Wait,” I say to my neighbor, “we shall perhaps chat about the news, too; but first I want to show you that you do not love the Jews.”

"Your proof. I don't contribute any money. I haven't any. The Germans have, so they give it."

"I don't mean exactly that.......You see, it is natural for the average mortal to desire to know everything, all details that concern a friend of his or a near relative. If you visit a relative of yours whom you have not seen in several years, you do not tire of asking questions: how he has been getting on in the intervening years, what he has gone through during the time; you ask how his wife and children are faring; if any member of the family has been sick, you want to know the illness, whether he suffered much, how long it lasted, what physician attended, what medicine he gave, etc...... And not alone such important matters. If he wears a new garment, you want to know what he paid for the material and how much the tailor; you even turn it over to examine the lining."

“Well,” smiled my friend, “that is certainly small talk.”

"Small talk, no doubt; but because it concerns your relative or good friend, you find time even for trifles and each little detail interests you.....But when you have brothers the entire world over, you do not care at all what is happening to them! And though your brothers have been suffering these thousands of years, you are not the least bit concerned to know what has happened to them during the whole time. From this it is to be inferred that you only say you have brothers, while in reality they are distant strangers to you; that in the blessing of the new month you pronounce the phrase, 'The whole people of Israel are brothers' with as much sincere fervor as you feel

when you say 'The coming year in Jerusalem.'"

"But after all I feel that I do love the Jews," my neighbor persists earnestly.

"You are mistaken," I say to him, still more earnestly.

"It is easy enough to say that."

"I can demonstrate it, provided you will only reply honestly to several questions."

"Well!"

"Do you love your relatives?"

"Not all."

“Why not all?”

“I am astonished at such a question!If a relative of mine opens up close tome a store just like mine (as though therewere not enough stores in the world),gets in my way, takes away my customers,my very bread—can I help being his enemy? Or, if I have (on my wife’s side)a relative who is a drunkard or an openviolator of the Sabbath—must I lovehim?”

"And besides these?"

“Besides these—yes! That is, all relatives whom I know.”

“And those whom you don’t know ?”

“I can’t say. I have, for instance, a first cousin in America; I have never laid eyes on him...........

"Then you feel towards him?" I interrupted.

“No enmity, but likewise, no friendship; for I really can't picture him to myself. It's like trying to love a vacuum or the hole of a bagel, so long as I don't know him.”

"And do you know the Jews in general?"

My friend begins to feel like a mouse in a trap and seeks to extricate himself with sophistries.

"What is the use of your ingenious explanations?" I say to him. "You do not love the Jews in general because of them collectively you have no conception. You love a few Jews, twenty, thirty, or say fifty; but the Jews you cannot love because you do not know them."