The Maccabaean · Vol. XVII, No. 6 · December 1909
202printed page
scan 20 of 52

bride's father is a man of orthodox tendencies, he will get a judge who is somewhat orthodox; and if the father is a radical, he will get a radical judge. And then they will invite the rabbi—in his capacity as an ordinary drinker only, of course! Your pardon for the humor," he added, with a deep bow to Dr. Schulman.

* * * *

After muzzling the discussion of the intermarriage question before it began, Thursday, the Conference voted to spread a propaganda of enlightenment and reform among the narrow-minded Yiddish-reading public.

* * * *

Of course, there was harmony and unity of opinion, and they all knew what Reform stood for when they entered upon it. Yet—

"I would like to ask one question," shouted Dr. Kohler, when the Bible was mentioned as a textbook in the Sabbath schools; "who is the better Jew—the man who believes in the Bible as such, or the man who does not believe in the Bible as such? I want to go on record as saying that I do not believe in the Bible as such. Those who say the Bible is the textbook of Judaism do not understand their religion."

Immediately there was a storm of protest.

Dr. Isaac Moses arose.

"I wish to correct the impression made by Dr. Kohler," he announced. "One thing and only one must be done in our religious schools; and that is to produce a reverence for the Word of God. And what is the Word of God? I am not the president of the Hebrew Union College; but for me the Bible, as it lies on my table, is the Word of God!"

"The Torah, the Torah!" shouted Dr. Kohler.

There was a discord of "Yes" and "No" in various parts of the room.

Rabbi B. C. Ehrenreich, of Montgomery, Ala., secured the floor.

"I am not a graduate of the Hebrew Union College," he announced. "Unlike anyone here, except the rabbi of this temple, I hold my degree from the Jewish Theological Seminary of America. I am not an orthodox Jew; but I am not an ultra-radical. I must admit, I have been unable to gather from the deliberations of this Conference, so far, what really is the meaning of Reform Judaism. We have been told by the President of the Hebrew Union College that the Talmud is not the Word of God; we have been told that the Midrash is not the word of God; and now we are told that the Bible is not the Word of God! I ask you, what are we to hold up to our children as the Word of God?"

Rabbi Philipson, descending from his place on the pulpit, assumed his chronic role.

"I wish to pour oil on the troubled waters,” he explained. “What Dr. Kohlerreally meant was simply this: that not onlythe Bible, but all that has been broughtforth by the spirit of Jewish traditionthroughout the centuries is the Torah.”

Dr. Kohler assented. The oil was poured. The Conference press agent sidled up to the reporters:

"You don't want to use that stuff," he suggested. Then, in a confidential whisper: "Kohler's an old man. You know."

At the cannibalistic feast of the rabbis at the Hotel Savoy the next night, it was objected that the press had misrepresented the spirit of the Conference by showing up the discord and neglecting the real deep business of the Conference. One Goyish reporter wondered what the real deep business was.

* * * *

Dr. Magnes, of Emanuel, in punishment for his freedom of speech at the Conference last year, was given only a Scriptural Reading on the program this time. He preceded Rabbi Enelow, of Louisville, the Conference Preacher. The Bible is the best weapon in an honest hand. Dr. Magnes read to the assembled