The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
25printed page
scan 25 of 52

Senator Lodge. I am not now speaking of political classifications. I am speaking of racial classification, and this is used by the Immigration authorities solely as a race classification. For the allegation that it is used as a religious classification I have seen no warrant whatever.

Mr. Mack. I can understand a racial classification from a country which does not classify its people racially, in which the race is recognized as a unit. Take it under the old Turkish rule; not as today.

Senator Lodge. Would you classify any Jew coming from Palestine as a Jew?

Mr. Mack. That would depend. There is a Jew from Palestine sitting next to me here who would be glad to be classified as a Jew, who would insist upon it. He pointed to Mr. A. Aronson, the agricultural expert and Zionist, who was present). But a great many would not, and there are a great many Jews in America who, if they go to Palestine, would insist upon beine classiied as Americans.

Senator Lodge. There is no discrimination whatever, as I understand. I should be the last man to favor any discrimination whatever.

Mr. Mack. I cannot understandthat when it comes to classifying Jewsfrom Germany or England or manyother countries as Jews. I can understand the proposition that there isno discrimination meant and no desire to get at religious differences, whenyou classify people of Austria as Croatians, Galicians, etc., and possibly even asJews, although Austria does not recognizethe Jews as a nation in the sense that itdoes the Bohemians, or the Croatians orthe Galicians. I can understand it in Rus-sa where they recognize different races;and so in Turkey under the old regime,where the Jews had certain national rightsas Jews; jurisdiction over their own bodies, among themselves, legally. But Icannot understand it from the standpointof Germany, of France or England or anyof those countries in which there is no

difference in which, just as in America, they are all deemed for every purpose, to be English or German or French.

Rep. Bennet. As 76 per cent. of those classified as Hebrews come from Roumania and Russia, as to which you admit a justification for the classification —

Mr. Mack. I do not admit the value. I am not prepared to discuss that. But I can understand reasons for a classification along the lines that the country itself classifies its people —not with respect to religion.

Mr. Wolf. I can easily understand that, from the standpoint of ethnology, you would be trying, from a scientific standpoint, to get at this subject.

Senator Lodge. That is the precise point. This is purely an attempt to get at the ethnology of it. It must be approximate. All ethnology is approximate.

Mr. Mack. I am afraid ethnology is not in a position at the present date to form the best basis. Ethnology has not advanced that far.

Senator Lodge. You can go approximately that far.

Mr. Mack. You can divide the world into five races.

Mr. Wolf. I do not ignore the fact that when you state that so many Jews are coming to the United States, it creates a feeling and sentiment among a class of people, who are entirely ignorant and prejudiced. It is a prejudice that is entirely uncalled for, because they regard the Jew from an entirely different standpoint from that which I have no doubt this honorable Commission intends to take when it brings out its report. I have met it everywhere —on the rostrum, in the newspapers, in private conversation. The Honorable Mr. Wheeler, when he was Assistant Secretary of Commerce and Labor —and none better ever sat in that chair— had quite a number of conversations with me on the subject, and, gentlemen, it is the absolute truth that when you classify these immigrants as Jews, the anti-immigration leagues of the country, the anti-