The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 1 · January 1910
3printed page
scan 3 of 52

with the facts. What is meant when it is said that Zionism must transfer its center of gravity to Turkey? Does it mean that we must study the conditions of the Turkish empire as closely as possible, follow every change with the greatest attention, enter into relations with its leading personalities and with all parties and enlighten them and public opinion as to our efforts, our means and ends. That is so obvious that it hardly needs articulation, at any rate in so excited and alarming a tone. We have been doing all this hitherto. We shall continue the work with devotion and industry, and our work in the future will, we hope, be rendered easier by the greater liberality of the laws and administration in the Turkish empire. The Turkish empire did not attain importance for us through the recent revolution. The object of all our hopes, our desires and our labors is a portion of the Turkish Empire. At the coast and frontiers of Palestine Turkish soldiers are on guard. The keys of the house, which the Zionists desire to make their home, are in the hands of the Turkish government. All our aspirations point to Turkey, like the needle of the compass to the magnetic pole. All our living undertakings, our schools, our Orient Bank, our Information bureau, our experimental farm, are situated in Palestine, i. e., in Turkey. All the practical undertakings we have devised and instituted are within the confines of the Turkish empire. We have for years attempted to study as thoroughly as possible the prevailing law, the legislation and administration which hold good in Turkey. Members of our organization are in Turkey to keep our organ informed of everything affecting Zionism and to work in its interests. In present conditions what more can be done? The leaders, we are told, ought to transfer their headquarters to Constantinople, to Palestine, and our Congresses ought to be convened there.

Honored Congress! To assemble the representatives of Zionism from both hemispheres in Turkey would have been premature so long as we are not certain that

Turkey was benevolently disposed towards our aspirations. Moreover, the transfer of the headquarters of our movement to the Turkish Empire would have been a serious mistake.

OUR TASK A DOUBLE ONE.

For we must never forget that our task at present is a double one, an internal and an external. It is certainly necessary to win for Zionism the approval of Turkey, the assistance of the Turkish Government, but it is just as necessary that we win for it the sympathy and support of the Jewish people. I do not know if, in saying this, I am leading up to something incompatible with so-called practical Zionism. But I am of opinion that our most important task is not the immediate opening up of official relations with the Turkish government, but the strengthening and the spread of the Zionist idea and the Zionist faith among the Jewish people. Awake from your self-deception; be not deluded nor beguiled. Count your numbers. Measure your strength. Do you really believe that we are already strong enough to create institutions in Palestine, of such significance for Judaism and the future of the Jewish people as to involve as a natural consequence that Palestine shall become the axis of our movement, the headquarters of our leaders? I do not believe it.

I am rather of opinion that we are still deplorably weak, and must extend our organization, let us acquire hundreds of thousands of new adherents, let us double, increase tenfold our activity in the Jewish centers of Europe and America. This very morning we have heard encouraging words from the lips of Dr. Levy and Dr. Frank, who pointed out the right means for fulfilling this task. Once we have accomplished it we shall be justified, on the basis of figures, in claiming for Zionism that it represents the organized Jewish people in the diaspora. We can then, with different prospects of success turn to our external tasks; we can then in quite a different attitude approach the Turkish government and lay before it our proposals. But our