The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
152printed page
scan 2 of 52

no foe has ever written about us before. He writes exactly the opposite of what he once said about Zionism. Whoever read his speech at the Article Club on the Commercial Future of Palestine, or his speeches delivered at the Congress, will know that he is now stultifying himself. Formerly he cried Palestine up to the skies; now Palestine is the worst place on the face of the earth

EVERYTHING ZIONISTIC DEAD, ACCORDING TO ZANGWILL.

Formerly Zionism was the only solution of the Jewish question, now it is the worst movement that exists. I do not propose to go into details, but I should like to point out the pessimism to which Zangwill gives expression at the close of his article. He concluded by stating that everything connected with us is bankrupt, is dead. The Zionist idea is dead, Zionism is dead, Palestine is bankrupt, the Jewish people is dead, Territorialism in his opinion is dead, everything is dead for him, and I do not think it nice of such a cultured man as Zangwill to say so many unpleasant things of the dead. Zangwill can be glad that he is not a prophet. If he had been a prophet he would have met with the fate of Elijah.

You probably know the legend. When Elijah fled to the wilderness he complained bitterly to God about the Jews, had nothing but bad to say about them and even went so far as to say: “They have broken Thy covenant, they have not kept faith with Thee” And God punished Elijah and said to him: “ From henceforth thou. shalt appear personally at every berith and be convinced that thy report is not quite correct. Thou hast no right to speak thus.” How would Zangwill feel if he had tu attend every Zionist meeting, every Congress, to see that Zionism is not dead, but lives? How would Zangwill feel if he had to go to every Jewish society, gymnastic association, Hebrew club, literary society. if he had to go through Palestine and see what Zionism has created,

what we can accomplish, and how our old land has awakened to new life?

THE SUCCESSOR TO HERZL.

It is his good fortune and perhaps ours also that Mr. Zangwill is no prophet. He does not even claim to be one. But there ‘is something that he claims. He has said that he is the natural successor to Herzl. I heard that from his own lips. I can see only one point of resemblance between Herzl and Mr. Zangwill, that Mr. Zangwill, like Herzl was, is a great author and poei. I see no other points of similitude. Herzl was a great poet, but it does not follow, on that account, that every poet is a Herzl. Herzl was a poet, but he was also a practical politican. When he set to work to give practical effect to the idea of the Jewish State he immediately mastered the Zionist idea, and at once ‚gave his adherence to Zionsm. He became a Zionist. But when Zangwill commenced to carry out his own ideas he separated himself from Zionism, would no longer remain a Zionist. Dr. Herzl united the Jews, united the Jews of one way of thinking, created Congresses; he brought the Jews scattered all over the world, together. Zangwill’s first act, when he started carrying out his ideas, was to secede from the organization. Herzl created financial institutions, the Jewish Colonial Trust, the National Fund, which, after all, have no other purpose than to colonise Palestine and settle Jews there. Zangwill’s first act however, was to fight these institutions, to conduct actions at law against them, in order to injure our Bank. Herzl, however, conducted negotiations with the English Government in respect to EI-Arisch, which lies beyond the Turkish frontier, and when the negotiations failed because we could not colonise ElI-Arisch, there developed the negotiations in respect of East Africa. Herzl entered into the matter. He thought we could create in East Africa a so-called Nachtasyl. Zangwill wanted the same after we had already sent a Commission