The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 5 · May 1910
154printed page
scan 4 of 52

icism as such; I am merely concerned with the way the criticism is conducted. It is, for intance, asserted that I am a political Zionist and am against practical work. At the Congress I asked for a single delegate to come forward and show me how I had been against practical work. From the minute I entered the movement I have done nothing else but practical work for Zionism. To-day, also, to-day in Palestine and at every other time! Perhaps it is that I understand by "practical work" something different from that in the minds of those who criticise. My "practical work" includes political Zionism. They say that a political Zionist ought not to be a Zionist. I believe that every Zionist who belongs to the organization must be a political Zionist.

What is the difference between political and practical Zionism? The Chovevi Zion, which regarded practical work as an end in itself, which bought a little land and settled a few Jewish peasants—that was certainly a great work. But political Zionism, the Zionist organization may only undertake work which is not an end in itself but means to an end, means for our great idea Let me explain with a little example. We placed two million francs at the disposal on the Anglo-Palestine Compan. If we had employed it on the lines of the Chovevi Zion, we should, at the most, have been able to settle 100 Jewish familie. But the Anglo-Palestine Company has been able, with its two million francs, to assist thousands—it helps all the Jews in Palestine, not merely individuals,. If we had utilised the 100,000 francs which the National Fund has given to the Bezalel on the old system, we should have been able to settle five. or perhaps seven families. But the Bezalel is now providing a livelihood for 100 Jewish families in Jerusalem, and it will assist many thousands more in time to come.

PETTY WORK NOT AN END IN ITSELF.

That is the difference. We must not engage in petty work as an end in itself.

In everything we do we must keep the great object in view and only carry out such work as conduces to the accomplishment of our great end. In everything that we do in Palestine, we must observe great caution. We cannot blindly undertake everything that is proposed. We must not allow ourselves to be forced by our Russian friends into projects before we know whether they will turn out well. Our brethren in Russia are going through evil days; they have a hard time of it and it is natural that they cannot wait. They must go forth. But will things be any better if we make a mess of our work in Palestine?

When we founded our trust in London, the rich Jewish financiers here prophesied that it would not last more than two years. They said that no business could be done in a movement in which everyone has something to say, that no bank could be carried on under such conditions, that in a short time it would fail. These people, who so prophesied, would have been right if we had not with iron fists resisted the pressure that was put on us, if we had not stood watch and ward over the few pence that the Jewish people had entrusted to us.

The people who manage the bank, Heer Kann, who is present with us to-day, our friends Cowen and Greenberg—how are they rewarded? Do you not think it would be pleasanter for them if they could fulfil all wishes, if they could be amenable to all desires, in order to acquire popularity? We have to thank them that, in spite of tl:e pressure, in spite of the criticism, they can say, “We have been placed at this post and what has been entrusted to us we will guard” Our friends who demand practical work, certainly mean well. But they do not understand and do not work themselves. I will give you a little example. Dr. Weitzmann, one of the best of Zionists, one of the leaders of the opposition in Hamburg, Dr. Weitzmann who las worked all his life for our cause, and who is with us body and soul, said at the