The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
208printed page
scan 22 of 54

VIEWS AND REVIEWS

THE IDOL OF AMERICANIZATION.

THE superior American patriots of the Jewish persuasion who aim and pretend to be better Americans than the aborigines have again been rudely awakened from their beautiful dream. This time some true and wise words have been spoken to them by Mr. Chester J. Teller of New Orleans, who read a most suggestive paper “On the Americanization of the Jew,” before the Convention of the District Grand Lodge No. 7 I. O. B. B, which was recently held at Mobile, Alabama. Mr. Teller sees the absurdity of prostrating ourselves and professing that we are the best Americans that ever happened and detects a danger in laying so much stress on Americanization without at the same time giving as much thought to the preservation of our own traditions and Jewish ideas. He sees the possibility of our being good Americans without in the least diminishing our fervor and our efforts in behalf of Judaism. He sees also that it is a waste of time and effort to propogate the ideal of Americanization among us when the natural conditions of our coming and staying here necessarily tend to identify us with the life of the country. Mr. Teller asks:

"Should a people develop along its line of least resistance? Are we not already suffering from too rapid adaptation? Are we not already too prone to lose sight of the old in our frenzy for the new? If lack of sympathy for parents among the children of Jewish immigrants, concerning which so much has been written, is to be ascribed to any one cause more than to another, that cause is over-Americaniza-

tion, by which the child is alienated from his own, in language, in manner, in customs, in thought, in ideals, in all that turns the hearts of the children to the hearts of the parents."

He then goes on to say:

“A vain cry it is then, this Americanization. The Jew does not need it, the world does not demand it. If we read current history aright, the world expects us first to be Jews, to assert first of all our Jewishness and to revere first of all our Jewish institutions. The Germans are always styling themselves German-Americans, the Irish, Irish-Americans, and we reward their candor with our praise. For my part the love of the German in America for the fatherland after years of alienation, and the passion of the Hibernian for Erin, though he may no longer remember it, is an inspiring thought. Patriots these; they deserve our praise, their affection for the soil that gave them sustenance furnishes their strongest claim to the title of true Americans. In the absence of any so-called Jewish American societies, we ought to rejoice in the work of our Jewish national organizations. The charge so often made against them, that they are lacking in loyalty to this country is as true as would be a similar attack directed against the Germans and the Irish; only it is significant here that this indietment against the Jew always comes from within his own fold.

“And if it is vain, the cry of Americanization, so is it likewise unmanly. For as Jews we look back over four thousand years of undying history. As Americans but a century or two. Americanism but blossoms in our hearts. Judaism is rooted