The Maccabaean · Vol. XVIII, No. 6 · June 1910
212printed page
scan 26 of 54

on methods in the Zionist organization. While the program as outlined by Messrs. Bentwich, Sacher and Simon involves a a number of questions on which there may be a serious difference of opinion, we are confident that what these gentlemen have to say on important Zionist issues is open to discussion on a plane altogether different from the kind of discussion that usually arises in conventions where the so-called Russian delegates are in control. In other words, this manifesto is an indication of a new spirit in Zionist circles, a spirit that allows for differences of opinion, but which speaks out in terms of democratic candor, minus the hair-splitting theories of those with whom Messrs. Bentwich, Sacher and Simon "desire to express their solidarity."

At least whatever the manifesto contains is not an expression of the intellectual fever, which characterizes the arguments of our brethren in the Muscovite empire.

There is no Zionist who seriously objects to the enlargment of the Smaller Actions Comite; to the removal of the headquarters to some centre of Jewish life; to the assignment of each member of the Smaller Actions Comite to some definite branch of Zionist work; to the strengthening of the Greater Actions Comite; to the organization of a representative body of Zionists in Palestine under the control of a member of the Actions Comite. These are matters to which every Zionist who is informed on conditions in Europe will agree, but as in all matters of administration, everything depends upon the practibility of these reforms.

To use the term practical without regard to actual conditions is sheer folly. If there is no representative Zionist in Palestine, no amount of wishing will bring him there. If there are not enough competent Zionists to man the ship of organization in some centre of Jewish life, the desirability of such a transfer is irrelevant. An Actions Comite, moreover, a committee of administration, a working committee, cannot be organized with mem-

bers in Palestine. Germany, Russia and England. It is simply impossible for such a committee to work together.

be Sale ern a An AUSB na a Sl amt Sr de Zadar an Der a EEE 1 den A EEE a Degr ald dal fer Wäthout going \any {further into the manifesto, it is apparent that the reform program is a matter for earnest discussion in which partisan prejudices have no place. It is idle for the framers of tlie manifesto to assert that they “desire to express their solidarity” with the cause of the Russian delegates and to make arbitrary distinctions between Russian, Germıan and English Zionists. As a matter of fact, we in the United States who disdain to call ourselves Russian Zionists, although we may have much in common with that class of Zionists, find ourselves is agreement with the general ideas of that party, although on questions of practicality, we part company at many points. We venture to assert that the moral prestige of the Russian Zionists is not superior to any other group of Zionists. It serves no good purpose, and is not in agreement with the facts, to assign all Zionist virtue to the Russians and by implication to minimise the value of other groups. None of these questions need be stamped as Russian, nor is it plausible to ascribe practicality to every project that emanates from the fertile imaginations of our Russian confreres.

If there are any .issues in Zionism to-day let us thresh them out without raising artihicial divisions between Zionists. The introductory matter to the manifesto, which we give practically in full elsewhere, is altogether out of place. The Russian versus German imbroglio does not interest us.

THE PITTSBURG CONVENTION.

THE task that will confront the Pittsburg convention of Zionists will require the intelligent consideration and continuous application of every Zionist who will attend it.

First of all, it is imperative that our convention take some definite action on the international questions of the move-