The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 1 · July 1910
22printed page
scan 22 of 50

THE MACCABAEAN

A Monthly Jewish Magazine devoted to the Zionist Movement and Jewish Life and Letters.

EDITORIALS

THE PITTSBURG CONVENTION.

THE thirteenth annual convention of the Federation of American Zionists, which will convene in Pittsburg on July 3d, meets under conditions that are pregnant with difficulties. The state of the movement abroad is not favorable, for factional differences and partisan quarrels never were beneficial to any organization or movement. And in this country, we are face to face with the fact, that in spite of our efforts of thirteen years, we have been unable to take advantage of the conditions favorable to our cause, owing to a lack of ability or lack of strength in effecting an organization that could garner the fruits of the Zionist agitation that has been going on here since the first congress.

It is not the lack of Zionist sentiment or Zionist hope that makes our course dificult. We have an abundance of these. The United States is pro-Zionist everywhere. We look with curiosity for an opponent who is whole-souled in his opposition. Every thing points to a general sweep of Zionist sentiment in this country, from the reformer to the ultra orthodox.

But our organization is powerless. It is ineffective. It is lacking in that strength, which is required of one who would lead those who have only the energy to become followers. Within it there is little or no directive influence that creates respect, that invites confidence, that leads the indifferent to become the enthusiastic.

No convention can provide a cure for this sort of weakness. No convention can create the tonic influences that shall purge the blood. But a convention may by clearing the board of all extraneous matter, arrive at certain conclusions, that shall, with continued subsequent effort, in time strengthen the weak parts of the organism.

When the word organization is used,

discipline and responsible activity is meant. That we lack. We have organizations, but no organization. There are many Zionist societies, but they do not form a Zionist organization. There is no responsiveness to command, there is feebleness in the word of command. Affiliation with the central organization is a tender thread easily snapped, seldom held taut, and never sufficiently strong to give either party holding the thread a feeling of security should it desire to test the strength of the thread. We are always eager to invent rules and regulations, but the spirit behind the rules we do not create. Our organization is too flabby.

The delegates who are supposed to give power to the executive committee elected by the convention, bring no power with them. They are not trained delegates, and it requires experience to be an effective delegate. Words are accounted for values, when deeds are impossible of execution, The convention, which should be the meeting place of persons inspired by great resolutions, filled with a knowledge of what their constituencies want, are usually confused meetings, lacking in purpose and in inspiration and in clearness.

A part of the cure is found in describing the disease. Let there be more discipline in the organization. Let the societies give more, they can then demand more of their executive committee. Let there be an inexorable repudiation of weaker brethren in the societies, then there may be an inexorable expulsion of weaker members of the executive committee. Let the societies report regularly to the executive; then call the executive to account for lack of reports from it to the societies. Let there be power below, then there shall be power above.

Do not blame others when the convention decides this way or the other. The convention is a free forum. There is no power that can hinder a majority from expressing its wishes. No rules of procedure, no precedent, no one man, can obstruct a majority when it is conscious of what it wants. If the delegates are democrats, they can procure a democratic convention. If they are still imbued with the spirit of the golus and listen without thought to proposals made to them, no delegate will know later why he obeyed in