The Maccabaean · Vol. XIX, No. 4 · October 1910
112printed page
scan 3 of 52

of the poorer classes and involving fundamental changes in the social order, must meet the powerful opposition of vested interests. We have but to recall the “June days” of 1848 in Paris and the establishment of the French Republic in 1871 to understand how difficult is the task of the social reformer in modern states. In short, wherever and whenever any steps in social evolution tend to jeopardize the profits or the privileges of our so-called upper classes there is a conflict which retards social progress.

The case is different with a proposed state. You will find no strong opposition party to a scheme for an Industrial Democracy in some far-off land. The self-interest of the captains of industry is not affected, and, accordingly, such an experiment is regarded. merely as a harmless Utopia. For example, the Zionist movement has created the National Fund, which, carried to its logical conclusion, means the approval of the principle of nationalization of the Jewish land. Yet we hear nothing but praise, for the National Fund, simply because there are no vested interests in the soil of Palestine. Among the many disadvantages of expatriation from the Jewish land, there is at least one advantage, namely, that, in constructing our state, we may avoid the clash between the selfish interests and the public welfare, and build our community in a true scientific spirit, divorced from the greed of materialism.

The outrages committed in the name of liberty, the wrongs perpetrated under the guise of fraternity, are not the necessary concomitants of Revolution. They are merely the manifestations of the spirit of destruction which usually precedes the period of construction in every revolution. Any fundamental reform in modern states means first a tearing down of the old institution before the rearing of the new. It is the resistance of the old, and not so much the innovation itself, that makes any .revolution so difficult. .

But in establishing a new commonwealth, we eliminate the struggle over the old intrenched political and social system. Where others have had to destroy and rebuild we shall have only to build. Like a man with no piece of land to call his own, we are "a people of air"; but when

we secure the plot upon which to build the House of Israel, we shall not be compelled to tear to the ground our former habitation. Profiting by the experiences of former ages and diverse nations, we shall be free to erect a Home for the Jewish People—a house that shall be artistic and stable, good to behold and a glory to inhabit.

Our critics may bid us wait until we shall have obtained the land before making plans and specifications for the structure to be erected, but the shrewd investor never buys before ascertaining how the land may be utilized. Furthermore, it will appear that the success of our movement depends, in a large measure, on a thorough understanding of the kind of state we shall build. Do we desire that it should rest upon the shifting sands of politics? Then our task may be very difficult and at the same time of doubtful value. If our aim is to create a social—moral community of Jews—a true Commonwealth— in Palestine, then our task is simpler, and our structure will abide. The lessons of history and the experiences of other nations may teach us how to build on a foundation of solid rock a house of many beauties towering to the skies. As the architect, in constructing a mansion, must acquaint himself not only with the tastes. of his patron, but also with the. work of the great masters and the teachings of experience, even so the great statesman— the builder of states—should profit by the experience of bygone ages and the history of nations. .

The French Revolution is justly regarded as the turning point in modern history, for a new element, hitherto ignored, manifested itself in human society. The French Revolution emphasized the sociaß aspect of history, while previousiy the political aspect was predominant. In the interval. with the wonderful growth of industry and science, the development of Socialism and the humanitarian movements for the amelioration of the condition of the poor, the social aspect has become increasingly important, until to-day the political element has already become subordinated to the social element in history. Indeed, if we examine 'the lives of the vast majority of the citizens of any country, we shall see how insignificant is