lationship. As to the concert of the friendly powers they are too busy with their own interests to bother about Zionism.
One official or another may be graciously inclined towards the Jew and Zionism, but the powers do not care a straw for it, and Zionists will have to fight their own battles to gain their ends.
History does not show us an example of a nation that bought its freedom and regeneration in the market place or received it as a present from somebody, but history does furnish many examples of how weaker nations had lost heir independence through the conspiracy of "friendly" powers. The fate of Poland conveys a good lesson.
"But the American Jew," says Mr. Simons, "proud of the long history of his race in this land as patriotic, law-abiding citizens, and striving to keep open its doors to his oppressed brothers of the East, has cause for anxiety in the espousal of socialism by the Jew." Here is where "the dog lies buried," as the Germans say. Mr. Simons is worried about the Eastern Jew, who since he left his native habitat has robbed the Western Jew of his peace of mind. All I have to say about these Western benefactors of the Eastern Jew is: "O, Lord, save us from our friends, our enemies we shall manage ourselves." As to striving to keep an open door, I shall say that only by sheer, brutal force, by mere might, but not by right, can the Eastern Jew be kept of this country.
Now, comes the last bit of wisdom from the mouth or pen of Mr. Simons: "With the education of the Jew in the spirit of our institutions and our laws, and with his
continuing achievement of economic independence, adherence to socialistic dogma will disappear, the Jew will be reclaimed from the economic error and continue to merit the welcome and justify the hospitality of America and its people."
This is exactly the language which according to Achad-Haam, the "freedom-in-servitude" class would use, but never a "free-in-spirit" Russian Jew.
I personally, having lived for years in England see nothing particularly majestic in American institutions and laws; far better and juster laws existed 2,000 years ago in a small country between the Mediterranean Sea and the River Jordan.
In ancient Judea a Sanhedrin that sentenced one man in seventy years to death was regarded as a cruel court, and after twenty centuries of the preaching of the gospel and development of civilization, culture, and a host of other good things we see hundreds of wretched men and women killed by legal decisions every year, and by industrial tyrants every day.
Mr. Simons' article on "Socialism and the Jews" betrays a lamentable lack of accurate knowledge and a strange ignorance of the facts of Jewish and general history. It shows a shallowness of argument which may pass a Summer Assembly of the Jewish Chautauqua, but it certainly deserves no place in a serious discussion. Not as a reply to Mr. Simons' article have I written this essay, primarily, but in order to counteract what ever influence his article may have with those who have read little of the history and principles of socialism as well as of Jewish history.