The Maccabaean · Vol. XX, No. 1 · January 1911
243printed page
scan 13 of 42

ter there is only one means whereby they can save themselves from entirely losing their love, and that is for them to place a great distance between themselves and the object of the affections, to forsake the reality and to continue to cherish the ideal.

Zionism naturally possesses two centers: Palestine and the Diaspora. The work, therefore, must be of two kinds; that which is to be done in the exile for Palestine, and the work to be done in Palestine in order to exert an influence over our people in the exile toward the creation of our own values. The greater part of the Zionists in the exile, who have been brought up under the conditions of the Goluth, are only fit for the first kind of work; the second kind must be given over into other hands,—into the hands of those who while yet living in the Goluth have inwardly freed themselves to give Palestine itself.

Dr. Kohan-Bernstein is a close friend of mine and still more than a friend, and when I observed his life in Jaffa and saw the spiritual sufferings which he was undergoing at every step, I thought to myself, this man will not long remain here. All about him the Hebrew language is blooming, his own children speak it; there is blossoming into life a new culture of which Dr. Kohan-Bernstein had dreamed in the exile. The dream is being realized, but he cannot longer dream; he has found no place for himself in the reality. He had long cherished the ideal, but its realization was strange to him. He did not understand the language in which the reality spoke.

But Mr. Zangwill remains lost in abstraction, even when he advises the Turkish Jews. I am greatly in doubt as to whether the Turkish Jews have really come to him with a question. We know how such "question and answers" are often manufactured. When the answer begins to itch, someone is soon found who will ask the question. I once knew a man who ran about among his acquaintances appealing pitifully for their help. "Friends," he said, "I have a beautiful little parable to tell, but I do not know what moral to point out." It is easier to save a friend with a "moral" than with a loan, and the man was soon helped out of his difficulty.

Zangwill cannot influence either the older or the younger elements. These elements of the new settlement themselves had developed before organized Zionism had come into being and their further development is not dependent upon Zionism alone. Mr. Zangwill has only dealt with the external aspects of Zionism and did not penetrate the subject far enough to see the roots out of which Zionism has sprouted. He does not understand that the Zionist phenomenon is no more than the result of the impelling power of the law of self-preservation; that Zionism will disappear only when the strength of the Jewish people will have so dwindled that they will no longer be able to produce or create. So long ‘as the millions of Jews possess the spirit and the soul which has always animated them that spirit will not cease to yearn nor that soul to desire to draw near to the land from which flowered our first source of strength.

Zangwill is a product of the Goluth, and too much like a child of the Goluth has the conceived the whole Zionistic idea, with which he is contending with such bitterness and vehemence and with all the sharpness of his pointed pen. He is a product of the Goluth, for the greatness of the Jewish, spirit is alien to him, and he is not acquainted with the new products of this spirit, and he does not interest himself ‘with the revived Palestine. He does not interest himself for the reason that he does not understand the process which is now going on there.

Throughout, Mr. Zangwill remains a theorist and evidently does not wish to understand the difference between one kind of reality and another. He makes comparisons btween southern Europe, America 'and Turkey, applying his theory of the "melting-pot" to every one of these countries, without taking into account the great difference between these countries.

In Europe, and not in all parts of it, it is still possible to speak of assimilation with the dominant nation; in America, however, there does not as yet exist a dominant nation,—it is only now being created through the fusion of the different national groups, and the troubles of the Goluth may yet begin in the course of time. In Turkey, however, conditions are entirely different. Altogether that country posses-