Zangwill's Advice to the Ottoman Jews
Dr. Schmarya Lewin's Reply
MR. Israel Zangwill has written a letter to the Committee of La Tribuna Libera, of Salonica, in which he tenders advice to the Ottoman Jews in reply to the following question: "What should be done to conciliate the different Jewish national theories in order that Ottoman Judaism, sharing in one and the same sentiment, should be able to count upon the concurrence of all intelligences and all energies, and thus labor for its regeneration?"
Insofar as the Ottoman Jews have kept their faith, the line of religion, says Mr. Zangwill, is the line along which all can co-operate; another common platform will have to be found for those Ottoman Jews who have lost their simple faith in the Sinaitic law. This must be either Territorialism or Nationalism.
In his discussion of these two points, Mr. Zangwill disposes of Zionism in this manner:
"Territorialism is the theory of finding a home for the race in which Jews should be the prepondering element; in its narrower form of Zionism, Territorialism would limit itself to Palestine and its neighborhood. As the acquisition of a territory outside of the Ottoman Empire would effect you but little, I shall confine my remarks to Zionism. It is this narrower species of Territorialism which presses upon you most, since while all other Jews can afford to play with Zionism, to you on the spot it is a matter of life and death. I know nothing in the world's political history more grimly ludicrous than the position of the Zionists whose idea of geting a country is to talk about it at a safe distance, leaving you poor unfortunate Ottoman Jews to bear the brunt of their campaign.
"In the very last number of the Jewish Chronicle I read the following paragraph:
"Dr. Kohn-Bernstein, an active Zionist
worker, has with his family left Palestine, where he has resided for the past few years, to return to Russia. He gives as the reason for his departure his belief that Russia offers a much wider field for Zionist propaganda than Palestine."
“Here was a case of a Zionist who actually saw the grotesque absurdity of building up a Jewish country except from within, and vet even Dr. Kohan-Bernstein, we find, deems it best to escape back to Russia, where as a matter of fact Zionist propaganda is prohibited by law. The theory of working from outside Palestine was perhaps valuable in the period when the first object of Zionism was a charter from the Sultan or a guarantee from the Powers, which charter or guarantee could be more easily acquired through the wealth and influenece of the Jews in the diaspora than by the wretched Jewish population ir Palestine itself. The moment, however, this policy of a charter was abandoned there remained nothing but actual immigration into Palestine, and a slow. building קט of the Jewish position מו that country under the stimulus of a patriotic enthusiasm. I do not myself see how even under these conditions a people which is as yet only 12 per cent. of the existing population and holds under 2 per cent. of the soil can push its way to predominance, especially in the face of the closed door of Palestine and the refusal of the Government to sell land to the Jews already within. But even if this miracle of penetration were possible in the course of the ages—and the chronology of a people is not measured on the scale of the life of a man—even so it could never be accomplished by Jews who are not there but who prefer orating in Berlin or Odessa upon this inexpungable passion and -וזזהק otism for Palestine.
"The fact is that the Jew after nineteen centuries of abstaining from national politics of his own has lost all political