The Faults of Our Organization
By BERNARD G. RICHARDS
THE majority of our people live under dire and distressing conditions; the road to our emancipation is discouragingly long, and we are naturally anxious to see the great change. But when in human endeavor have deeds kept pace with words, have aims gone hand in hand with achievements? When have the realities measured up to the dreams? There must be a great deal of talking, and preaching, and planning, and striving before we can realize an approximate portion of that which we have aimed to achieve.
In my opinion, the Zionist organization is mainly an organization for talking, for holding the Jewish nationalist ideal up, before the Jewish people, for continual calling upon the Jewish people to emerge from the slough of despondency, to rise above their circumstances, and to fight for the realization of our historic destiny. If we will only talk, and write, and agitate long enough and effectively enough, the Jewish people will respond to our appeals and do the rest, and in divers ways and by different methods help in rebuilding the Land of Israel.
Our movement offers various spheres of activity; there is theoretic, or educational work, and there is practical or pioneer work to be done both from here and in Palestine itself, and each one can best choose the work which most appeals to him. But I, myself, am mainly interested in spreading the Jewish nationalist ideal, in making more and more Zionists. From this point of view, there is no reason for despairing over the situation. The Jewish nationalist ideal is taking deep root and spreading everywhere. It means that we are making more and more Zionists. After we have large numbers of enthusiastic and devoted Zionists, we can devise the methods and find the means of strengthening the present form of organization, and of bringing into existence new forms of organization which will probably be in a better
position to do the work of the time. Considering that we have been talking about the new form of Zionism for only about twelve years, I think we have realized more of our aims than is the usual proportion between striving and achievement.
Of course, we might, even despite the usual proportions, have achieved more. There have been many obstacles to impede our path. In the first place, most of our workers have been immigrants, strangers in a new land, going through the trying and painful ordeal of adapting themselves to new circumstances, learning a new language, acquiring new trades and professions, endeavoring to earn a livelihood and to find a place for themselves in the new society. Strangers like these have for a long time enough to do in building up their own homes, before they can extend any aid to the creation of the great Home for all our people. Then, too, we have lacked training in organization work, in parliamentarism, in the ability to express ourselves readily, to lend and to shape public opinions and the guidance which has often been extended to us by some of our American brethren, who have not understood us has only paralyzed our will and deadened our own initiative. During our early "greenhorn" days, some of the few native-born Zionists have awed us into a peculiar state of submissiveness from which we have never quite recovered. Between the meekness of the immigrants on the one hand and the boldness of the Americans on the other, a peculiar condition of inequality has been created from which the Zionist and other Jewish movements have suffered.
We have suffered mainly through desertion, through the fact that many former active Zionists have deserted our movement as soon as they have become prosperous, and have settled into the blissful state of being called Bal Habatim. An article which I recently saw in a Yiddish newspaper stated in the headline that "ven a Yid vert reich, vert er a Jehudi." Among the Yidden who