help anything that furthered progress, were the only two rabbis in favor of this Talmud Torah. But the founder of it, Rabbi Saul Benjamin Cohen, was a man of great energy who triumphed over the opposition of the Rabbis and won the sympathy of the people and the material support of the European philanthropists. The progress of the institution was so rapid that in a few years it became the centre of learning in Jerusalem.
In an article in the Hamagid, vol. 5, No. 27, Yehiel Bnil, in eriticising :Frankl’s book on Jerusalem, finds in the institution built by Rabbi Saul Benjamin Cohen the very best refutation of JFrankl’s bitter criticisms. He writes: “Let all those who read the calumniating and insulting words of Frankl on Jerusalem know that he has not spoken the truth about his unhappy brethren. \Vhoever wants to know about Jerusalem should come and see the Talmud Torah and the Seminary Etz Haim, which are flourishing ıfor three years. Let Dr, Frankl himself now come to Jerusalem and let him see what has greater success, whether the Talmud Torah, whıca is beloved by men and by God, or the school which he has established here. And if he really likes the truth as he pretends he does, he will not be unwilling to confess that the Talmud Torah is flourishing and fructifying, while the school will never flourish, nor answer in any way to the needs of Jerusalem.”
The Rabbis, however, were looking with a jealous eye upon the rapid development of this Talmud Torah, and were eagerly awaiting the occasion for an open attack. The occasion presented itself when the Prussian consul gave a report of this institution, which was to be sent to the European philanthropists. In this report, the consul refers to the Talmud Torah as the Bildungs Anstalt of Jerusalem, instead of its usual name, Talmud Torah. As Bildung generally means profane learning, the consul’s expression created great alarm in Jerusalem. A meeting for effecting a remedy for this great evil was soon held by Rabbi Leib Kutna, the author of Zaith Ra’anan, Rabbi Meir Auerbach, the author of Imre Binah, Rabbi Nachum Beharama, Rabbi Samuel Salant, and all the trustees of the “Kolelim.” They decided to prohibit the directors of the Tal-
mud Torah from sending abroad their annual report, which also contained the consuls favorable letter upon the institution. To make the prohibition more emphatic, they condemned publicly in the Hamagid, vol. 5, this dangerous and heretical report. The following is an abstract of their article in the Hamagid: “We saw last week on Wednesday some letters signed by Saul Benjamin Cohen, which were supposed to be sent to Europe asking for the support of the Talmud Torah and the Seminary Etz Haim. We ourselves, with our own eyes, saw those abominable letters and we deplore them bitterly, Those letters, which contained a copy of the recommendation given to the institution by the Prussian consul, would have created the false impression upon our brethren of Europe that ‘Bildung’ (culture) is taught in Jerusalem. Oh! what a shame it would have been for Jerusalem and for the whole world if this were true. No, there is no such attempt to teach ‘Bildung’ in the Holy Land. We, therefore, in the name of the Holy Torah, under the penalty of excommunication, order that those letters should not be sent to Europe. And although those guilty of this sin are as great as the cedars, let them fall down from their heights, if they do not abide by our command.” This article, strange as it may appear, found a strong echo in the great Rabbi of Grodez, (Germany), Eliohn Guttmacher, who. also became distressed over the tabooed words Bildungs Anstalt. He writes in the Hamagid: “Hasten brothers, hasten to remedy the evil of unreflecting sinful souls who come to blind the youth and bring thorns and poison into the streets of Jerusalem. Jerusalem, holy eity, lift up thy eyes and see how strangers come to desecrate thy sanctity. Jerusalem, our mother, arise in the darkness of the night and pour out .thy heart like water before God.” But, thanks to the intervention of Rabbi Joseph Schwarz, the anger of Guttmacher was soon appeased. In an open letter in the Hamagid, Joseph Schwarz explains to Guttmacher the whole situation and praises very highly Rabbi Saul Benjamin Cohen, the foınder of the institution. Immediately after that, Rabbi Saul Benjamin Cohen went to see Guttmacher and won his friendship and sup» port. -
The historical development of this in-