ocrisy that it was an American question, not a Jewish question. And when there burst upon us other happenings —the Rosenthal case—which especially distinguished this year from others, again that cry of conventional hypocrisy was raised: “It is a public question, a New York City question, not a Jewish question.” The gangsters, described in the police records as American Hebrews, may not be observantly religious Jews, but they are Jews by race and religious training.
It is intelligible that the non-Zionist should wish to repudiate them when he gives to the word Jew entirely a religious connotation. But with that sincerity of thought so characteristic of prejudices masquerading as principles, those who most vehemently maintain that the Jewish gunmen and gamblers should not be classed as Jews because they are not religiously observant Jews, are. vociferously eloquent in claiming Isidor Straus as a Jewish hero. They are proud of a Zangwill, but they repudiate a Big Jack Zelig. They glory in a Karl Marx, the son of a convert to Christianity, but disown a “Gyp the Blood.”
And the Zionist also cannot be declared free of a similar hypocrisy. Loud was the outery of many a Zionist against the police description, “American Hebrew.” The Zionist is as ready as the non-Zionist to raise the cry of anti-Semitism when a newspaper describes a malefactor as a Jew. But surely if the Zionist gives to the word Jew a racial meaning, he must be as content to see Aaron Moses, pickpocket, described as Jew, as to see Siegmund Schneider described as German or Patrick O’Halloran as Irish. And therefore, whether we approach the Rosenthal case with the convictions of Zionists or anti-Zionists, we must accept the gunmen as Jews—Jews by race, Jews by training and even Jews by religion. It is hard to imagine a more deplorable ostrich-like attempt to bury our head in the ground, than a puerile evasion to shift the responsibility to American conditions, when we are brought face to face with the most significant happenings in the Jewish year.
For the abortive abrogation of the treaty of 1832, the massacre of the Jews in Fez, Portugal's offer of pest-ridden Angola to the Ito, the orthodox conference at Katto-
witz, and other such outstanding events of the year are important, but they are not significant; they are typical of every year and they reveal to us nothing hew. But the Rosenthal case, with its sudden revelation to the whole community of the existence of a large class of Jewish criminals, depraved with every vice, discloses to us a condition pregnant with startling meaning. Whether we blame American conditions or not for breeding this class, the fact remains that the type is being created in New York, London and other such centres. The Jewish professional gambler, procurer and gangster is a type logically and inevitably produced in our exile, where religious education is necessarily ineffective against the irresistible and overwhelming influence of the non-Jewish environment. Golus will of necessity continue to give us “Rosenthal cases,” and revelations far more appalling when it publishes to the world the full facts of the Tewish traflie in vice.
And therefore, this Rosenthal case brands mercilessly the utter failure of emancipation to solve the Jewish problem. It lays its finger sensationally on the weakest point in the pitiably weak system of Americanization, that has been offered us as the panacea for Jewish ills. It ridicules with the relentless logic of facts the hollow sententious claiıns of the doctrine of assimilation; and by revealing the extreme of the actual Jewish development that is going forward, it laughs to mockery the abstractediy beautiful, but utterly unreal, untrue and impossible claims of those who preach that we are scattered throughout the world in order to be a “Kingdom of Priests and a Holy Nation”—as if, forsooth, the Jewish gangman is to be the world’s teacher of righteousness, and the Jewish gunman and white slaver is to act as God’s witness on earth.
The Rosenthal case has set in juxtaposition the facts of life and the theory of our being scattered to be a light to the nations. It has put together the results of emancipation and assimilation and the claims of emancipation and assimilation, so that the very blind and deaf may see and hear that the facts and the theory, the reality and the abstract claims, are utterly and irreconcilably opposed.
But the Rosenthal case will be significant only if we learn its lesson,—that the pretentious and specious promise of eman-