The Maccabaean · Vol. XXII, No. 6 · December 1912
189printed page
scan 13 of 34

But nothing has been placed before the community, which is still merely a pawn in the movements of the Kehillah. As a matter of fact, the Kehillah for reasons unknown to us, has refused or neglected to appeal to the community. Its negotiations have been with interested rabbis. It has been using diplomacy to get them to relinquish their perquisites. It has had hopes of making amicable terms with the dealers and the rabbis, leaving the community altogether out of its calculations. It would rather consider the subsidized rabbis the masters of the situation than go direct to the people.

It thus followed a course consistent with its entire policy. It avoided stirring up public opinion and preferred relying on conferences in camera with small groups of men. The Schechitah problem is not solved. The method of approach is wrong. It ought to be apparent now to the Kehillah that nothing effectual can be done without a direct appeal to the congregations, and to the larger community.

This, then, is the ailment that afflicts the Kehillah. It lacks the essential attribute of democracy. Nor is this a matter of mere academic importance. It goes to the root of apathy and indifference in the community.

Once the sense of responsibility for Jewish affairs is communal, you have a weapon against every indifferent Jew. The philanthropies of the city are maintained by one per cent. of the Jewish population. The individual has been made to feel that he has not an equal responsibility for Jewish conditions with the men who are so largely the maintainers of our institutions.

Without responsibilities duties are not recognized. The men who give are compelled to give more from year to year. The more they give the less others give, and the less others feel that it is their concern. The responsibility should be distributed. The community is demoralized by the swollen individual benevolence of the few.

The Kehillah has never made a test of the proposition. It was organized for that purpose, and yet, in every instance where a test could have been made, it has taken the line of least resistance, where its ability to lead has been more secure against public challenge.

It may be said that a majority of the leaders were opposed to the Kehillah ideal when they became a part of the movement; that they expected to stem the tide that seemed to lead to dangerous innovations. They may have felt that for the time being they must compromise with public clamor in order later to control it.

But having given life to a Kehillah, they are bound to let it be true to its functions. They must compromise with their own notions of Jewish policy a little bit further. They cannot hope to maintain a Kehillah which denies the fundamental principle of its being. If a democratic Kehillah is not to their liking, they must destroy it altogether. The present anomalous conditions cannot be justified or continued. If it is not to be the representative of a democratic community, it will sink lower and: lower in the public esteem, until even the men responsible for its condition will be reluctant to be known as its sponsors. Does: not a sham Kehillah hinder the proper organization of the Jews of this city?