The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 5 · May 1914
139printed page
scan 13 of 34

from one to the other and has no clear consecutive policy with regards to either. It takes up the immediate task in Palestine. But it has no time for planning. It responds to immediate calls. Its force is terribly undermanned. Its means for these various projects are wofully inadequate. On the other hand, as the creator of national sentiment, it is undecided how to proceed. The propaganda is conducted for definite practical purposes, with imposing budgets, with concern for the pressing and often vociferous demands of impatient people who fear that Palestine may be removed from under the feet of the Jews.

This is the great danger: The organization cannot forever be both the singer and the song of Zionism. In other words, it is impossible to be at the same time the propagandist of national ideals and the colonizing agency in Palestine, unless it has a period of rest for the upbuilding of its internal life. The organization has thrown itself into Palestine work without providing for its own continued, efficient existence. There must be a line drawn between the organization working for national ends and individuals working for themselves, and indirectly for national ends. Such a division can be made. This should be the leading principle: Whatever an enlightened, progressive government would do under the circumstances, the Zionist organization should undertake. But the government should not be submerged by its departments. It should rise above them.

II

Because the Actions Comite, our government, has been operating in this dual capacity, we in America have also suffered. We have been made the collectors of funds. We have engaged in propaganda only with an eye to secure the funds. Now and then, we have had a respite. But the entire tone of Zionism has become one of immediate work measurable in dollars and cents.

The policy governing the acquisition of funds has been one leading to organization bankruptcy.

Under rational conditions, had the Actions Comite taken the precaution to protect the interests of its branch federations, propaganda by means of concrete enterprises would not have resulted in re-

ducing the American federation to impotence. For if the federation would have been allowed to maintain itself from the funds collected, it would have profited by the work it did for the funds. But the donors to the funds felt no obligation to the organization, for the emphasis was being placed on money and not on organization. The contributor to Palestine institutions thus had an advantage over the organization Zionist. The organization Zionist unable to contribute to Palestine institutions felt guilty, although he was the generous donor. He felt that if only he could give too, he would be absolved from doing the chores of the organization. And as he became prosperous, he either contented himself with some money gifts, or dropped out of the movement entirely. Thus the Federation did not grow as the funds grew, but on the contrary, every new fund meant organization sacrifices, in time, money or individual service.

The policy of the Jewish National Fund Bureau for America, according to which the collections pay for the work involved is an indication of what should be the system. The Bureau, operating under the close supervision of the Cologne office, pays for all work done for it. The larger the collection, the larger will be the budget. But even here, no provision is made for maintaining that large organization activity, without which the Bureau could not have succeeded in raising its annual income from $8,000 to $40,000 in the course of about four years.

The Federation, as well as the Actions Comite, is limited to its per capita tax, which is absurdly inadequate. Special propaganda funds are solicited, but it is with difficulty one works against the prevailing sentiment that one cent for Palestine is worth more than fifty for propaganda and organization. This sentiment is Zionism at its lowest ebb. It must be combatted, for if it continues to prevail, Zionism is soon bound to face disaster.

I come now to another feature of organization in America. It is a reflection of the same lack of courage in fighting for nationalism frankly and openly, without subterfuge or indirection. The Actions Comite favors subsidiary organizations in Palestine, instigated by the Zionist movement, but not controlled by it. So