The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIV, No. 5 · May 1914
148printed page
scan 22 of 34

Zionism has kinship with social reforms, social strivings and social ideals. Dr. Herzl instinctively and recognized this, for in the "Judenstadt" and "Altneuland," he portrays a great Jewish Commonwealth, in which the laborer works only seven hours a day, and where co-operative efforts make possible the realization of the social dreams of the prophets.

Do not misunderstand me. I do not pretend that Zionism is only the prelude to the establishment of a Socialist Commonwealth in Palestine. I do not know what kind of a Commonwealth we shall erect. But of this much we may be certain: the Hebrew Commonwealth will incorporate social reforms, and will foster social ideals, to a much larger extent than any other government, ancient or modern, for the very simple reason that this Commonwealth will derive its being and draw its strength from the social character of the Jew.

My personal view is that our Commonwealth in Palestine will be socialistic rather than Socialist —it will strive towards social reforms and social justice without, necessarily, becoming a full-fledged Socialist State. I believe that love of liberty is too firmly intrenched in Jewish character to permit the organization and development of a form of Socialism, which, as it is understood to-day, requires the exercise of a considerable amount of coercion. For in spite of all denials to the contrary, the Socialist concept necessarily implies the utilization of coercive power, since in order to accomplish the unpleasant tasks of life, it will demand and receive the unwilling obedience of many citizens. To illustrate: it will require no great effort to produce orators and statesmen who will deliver weighty addresses in well-filled banquet halls, but it might require some amount of gentle force to obtain sufficient persons to prepare the banquet table. Social justice does not abrogate the principles of individual

justice. I am unwilling to compel any man to co-operate with me throughout life, even though I be firmly convinced that my prescription is most essential to his well-being and success.

I firmly believe in co-operative effort. But our co-operation must be a voluntary offering of a freedom-loving people, not a haphazard labor union superimposed by the state. In short, I favor a system of "Voluntary Socialism," or the organization of a Commonwealth that will permit the individual to enter joins the Masons or a Zionist society and share in the benefits of socialized industry; but he must not be denied the privilege of staying out of the co-operative society, and compete, if he so wills, with the Socialist state, in the publishing of a newspaper as well as in the manufacture and sale of furniture, clothing, etc. Even as we have free public schools to-day, that might be utilized by the children of all our citizens, and yet we place no hindrance on the establishment and growth of private schools and colleges, so we should accept the principle of a Social Commonwealth that will endeavor to secure for its members the full rewards of their labor (in compliance with Socialist demands), without interfering, however, with private industry and individual initiative.

The Jewish National Fund is struggling to obtain possession of the soil of Palestine as the heritage of the Jewish people, with the fixed purpose that the Jewish nation itself will be the one great landlord in our future Hebrew Commonwealth. Dr. Franz Oppenheimer, and those who sympathize with his views, are the precursors of the next step in the social evolution of the Jewish settlement in Palestine. And I have faith that such next step will be the creation of a "Social Commonwealth in Zion," which will exist in competition with individual initiative, and not to the exclusion of private enterprise.