The Maccabaean · Vol. XXV, No. 1 · July 1914
5printed page
scan 5 of 46

biassed information with regard to the whole affair.

Mr. Schiff felt called upon to publish his letter at a time when I happen to be in New York. He thereby forces me to revert to the language controversy, which I had intended not doing during my present visit. What brought me to America this time is of far greater importance than the Haifa Technicum. The Technicum is only one phase of the movement. I feel, however, that Mr. Schiff should have remembered the Perek, "Wise men should be careful with their words." especially in the matter of giving warnings. The Zionist movement is too large, and has too great a meaning for the Jewish people, to be so treated. Its strength lies in that it is awakening the Jews to the new life, and no one should assume the authority to come now with new soporifics. The Jewish people know the efficacy of these sleeping potions, and will. I hope, be little influenced by them.

Leaders in Jewish communal affairs should not have two standards for weighing and measuring. They should not be as pliant as a whip to one side, and as firm as a ceder to the other, for a building which has a foundation only on one side must eventually topple over.

To the letters of Dr. Levin and of the Federation, Mr. Schiff made the following reply, modifying, in the first and last paragraphs the most offensive part of his attack on the Zionist organization. His letter follows:

To The American Hebrew:

The chairman of the Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists is mistaken when in his recent communication to you he complains of a deliberate attempt on my part to discredit the Zionist organization. Nothing is further from my intentions. He avers that it is not of interest to Zionists how I was persuaded to become interested in the Haifa Technicum. Nevertheless, it has been repeated under Zionist influences—in The American Hebrew for instance, of which Chairman Lipsky himself is, I believe, an editor—that my interest in the Technicum was secured through Dr. Schmarya Levin, an unjustified assertion, apparently intended to make a capital for one of the principle lead-

ers of the Nationalistic wing of the Zionist organization, who was also, as is stated by those who claim to know the facts, one of the prime movers in the extraordinary campaign against the Technicum management.

Chairman Lipsky and also the New York Yiddish papers, which have been sent to me, deny that any but peaceful means were used in the "protest" in the so-called language conflict in Palestine. It must then be assumed that these writers are wont to regard public riot, smashing of windows of school-houses, threatening of, if not actual violence to, loyal teachers, parents and schoolchildren, the throwing of nauseating bombs into schoolrooms and other similar doings as "peaceful actions" and not as I and others do as reprehensible means to gain certain means. The fact is that members of the Zionist organization, both here and abroad, made haste after these occurrences to disassociate themselves from responsibility for and to condemn these practices, which the chairman of the Federation of American Zionists' Executive Committee now appears to defend as legitimate weapons.

It is, perhaps, proper that I should here state that the American members of the Technicum Curatorium were a unit in support of the claim that Hebrew should, as soon as proper teachers and text-books could be made available, which at this time is not yet the case, be adopted as the sole language of instruction in the Technicum. If instead of the hasty resignation of the three Zionist members of the Curatorium, and the subsequent resort to violence and, in its form, illegitimate agitation, in Palestine, the good offices of the American curators had been asked for by the three Zionist curators themselves, matters could no doubt have been readily adjusted and harmony maintained. When after the lapse of some time, the American curators found it, of their own accord, necessary to intervene, they obtained without difficulty all the Zionists had contended for, but the damage that had been done was already too considerable to prevent the breakdown which has resulted.

Some of the Zionists leaders have stated with entire frankness that the Zionist