amount of cattle raising, and the intensity of labor used in Germany agriculture today without the help of paid assistance. This answers our question as to the area necessary to allow a family to subsist by itself, in a social order, where there does not exist a laboring class.
Now Germany contains 34 million hectars of land suitable for agricultural purposes, but her agricultural population only numbers 17 million people. There is therefore room for just double the number of independent peasant families as exist there.
The same can be said of Great Britain today.
But far more than half of these 17 millions, representing the agricultural population of Germany, is composed of farm laborers without any rural property, while rather more than half the remaining population owns considerably less than one hectar per head. The explanation of these facts is found in the word closed-in land. Almost one-fourth of the whole area suitable for cultivation belongs to some 12 or 13 thousand landed proprietore, owning each over 100 hectars (not counting forests) and more than a second fourth is in the hands of some 225,000 farmers, who are forced to employ foreign laborers in order to farm their land. There can thus be no doubt that there exists in Germany a state of closing-in of the land of political occupation of the soil, and consequently the division into classes is the outcome of the political, not of the economical. means.
The same can be said of Great Britain with her immense latifundiary estates that Mr. Lloyd George is now attacking with such vigor; of Belgium, of Italy, of Austro-Hungary, of Russia, Roumania, and so forth.
But it is just as true for the countries where peasant-proprietors predominate like France, Switzerland, Holland, the United States of America. In all these countries there is room for a great increase of the actual number of independent peasant proprietors. Everywhere, however, we find a large mass of proletarian farm labourers and a strong percentage of dwarf-property. Wherever a larger area than one hectar per
head is needed we find the intensity of cultivation to be still low, and there the density of population is also low; wherever the density of population is high we find the intensity of cultivation correspondingly high and the necessary acreage is reduced accordingly. Thus for the West of Germany and for France, where the soil is richer and the climate more favourable, and where cultivation is at a higher level, the acreage necessary per head to ensure independence is found on an average to be only two thirds of a hectar or about 3 to 4 hectars per family ("at an average" means of course the poorer land and less favourable market conditions require more land and very favourable general conditions will allow a smaller acreage to be sufficient).
This certainly proves that Turgot and his successors were mistaken; and, further, that the division into classes is the result of political means; and finally, that the State divided into classes constitutes the developed political means. Without the closing-in of the land there would be even to-day, and for countless years to come, no division into classes, no labouring class, no latifundiary proprietors of real estate and no excessively rich capitalists.
V
In what measure does this now bring us nearer to a solution of our problem? Well, anarchism asserts that, as authoritative government has been always infected with exploitation it will be so infected throughout all future time. We have now shown this deduction to be a simple contention by analogy and are able to affirm its being fundamentally wrong, because the ward "state" is applied here to two different phenomena: the antique and the modern state divided into classes, and the state free of all class divisions that is to come. These two phenomena are as contradictory as the different roots from which they spring: the political means for the one and the economical means for the other. It is easily understood that, with the state divided into classes, all authority vested in functionaries, every official position as judge or as general, as Mayor or as tribal king, as member of par-