The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 5 · May 1915
91printed page
scan 10 of 20

A Course In Zionism

(Outline used by the Hadassah Group of the Zionist Training School, and by some other groups. All inquiries should be addressed to Miss Jessie Sampter, 31 West 110th Street, New York City, N. Y.)

SYLLABUS 2.—NATIONALISM.

1. Nationalism is the sense of cultural identity among the individuals of a political or historic group. Spiritual and intellectual power. (a) Nationalism is impossible without history. (b) It results from finely adjusted inter-relation and organization. (c) It is a late development of highly civilized peoples. 1. Nationalism in the Orient. In barbarous surroundings it leads to isolation. Compare Chinese wall and Jewish laws of separation. 2. Nationalism in Europe. A new development of the last century. In the uniform development, it will not lead to isolation. Language, customs, culture, the safeguard of national individuality in Europe. (d) It culminates in internationalism. 2. Imperialism is the desire of a governing group to dominate peoples of differing identity. Physical expansion. (a) Destroys natural boundaries and national individuality. (b) Weakens the individuality of the conqueror, who often absorbs other cultures. (c) Requires no high state of civilization, and only a physical organization. (d) Culminates in cosmopolitanism, with loss of art and distinctiveness. 3. Wars of conquest are the foes of nationalism. (a) They level cultural distinctions. (b) Destroy individuality of small nations. (c) Peace accentuates distinctions. 1. All art is national. 2. Small nations and world progress. (d) Tyranny makes for likeness, freedom for variety 4. Nationalism is the foe of war. (a) Mutual understanding the safeguard. (b) Difference of language a spur to the appreciation of foreign cultures. (c) The difference between sameness and harmony 1. Harmony is the well-balanced relation between differing parts. 2. Sameness would lead to quarrels through clash of material interests. 5. Internationalism. (a) It implies nations. (b) It requires free trade and open door and free choice of citizenship. (c) Physical fluency must give chance for intellectual individuality. 1. Example, the human body. substance and spirit. (d) Distinctions between nations can be only cultural (e) Democracy of nations. (f) International morality. (g) Highest tribunal, the conscience of humanity. 6. Patriotism is a realization of the peculiar ideals for which one's nation or people stands, and a sense of personal responsibility for the furtherance of those ideals. (a) Loyalty is the underlying virtue in patriotism. (b) Value of patriotism depends upon the value of national ideals. 1. It is like the command to honor parents

which does not include sinful parents. (c) Patriotism is strengthened by national misfortune, therefore by war, but can no more be said to cause war than self-sacrifice can be said to cause war. (d) Internationalism no more destroys patriotism than national life destroys family loyalty. Large loyalties include smaller loyalties. 7. Jewish nationalism stands for: (a) Theocracy, that is religious democracy; (b) Absolutely impersonal law; (c) International morality; (d) Power through righteousness.

BIBLIOGRAPHY.

Nationalism and Universal Brotherhood ...Jessie E. Sampter (Hadassah Leaflet, two cents.) A Call to the Educated Jew .....Louis D. Brandeis (Menorah Journal, Vol. I, No. 1.) The Twilight of Hebraic Culture .....Max L. Margolis (Menorah Journal, Vol. I, No. 1.) Christian Ethics and Nationalism .....G. F. Balfour (International Journal of Ethics, Oct., 1913.) Nationality and the Hyphenated American...H. M. Kallen (Menorah Journal, Vol. I, No. 2.)

SUGGESTIONS FOR DISCUSSION.

1. National character consists of mental developments, such as language, manners, customs, tastes. The strongest bond, even of race, is the family and race tradition rather than the physical fact of birth. Therefore the force exerted by nationalism is emotional or spiritual, not physical. (a) It has been said that the United States is a state, but not yet a nation. Nationalism is organic. It means not only living together, but thinking and feeling together. (b) Nationalism, as the ideal of a people, means national coming of age, self-consciousness and self-knowledge. The ancient civilizations of the Orient, China, Japan, India, reached it long ago. They were conscious of their culture, their place and purpose, and they took means to protect themselves against deterioration through dilution with different and especially with less developed peoples. The Chinese wall had the same purpose as the Jewish laws of separation. The other ancient nations, aiming only at self-development, stagnated. The Jews, aiming at world-development, gave to the world the idea of progress. In Europe, just awakening to national self-consciousness, the nations are on a nearly equal plain of culture, and the differences in language, history, customs, are therefore sufficient protection for what might be called national privacy. (d) The word “international” is the opposite of “cosmopolitan.” It implies the existence of nations, and the intercourse between, them on a basis of equality and democracy. 2. Imperialism implies national subjection, and the slavery of one nation to another. It is purely physical, for the land conquered has no relation to the conquerors No nation has a right to own what any other nation needs for life, its land, its harbors, its government. (a) A land and its people are like a body and a soul Geography and climate determine national character, and every land has its natural physical boundaries. 3. (b) When Rome conquered Greece, when the Bar-