The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVI, No. 6 · June 1915
103printed page
scan 2 of 32

Jews. Never before in our history has so much work been done in one year. The press has teemed with Zionist information, discussions of nationalism, reports from Palestine, and over and above these details rose the great central question of Jewish life, the national problem.

Let us not think that the Convention means the end of a year's work; it means the beginning of another year's work. The situation is not clear; but there is no doubt that Palestine must still have our active and material support; and what peace will bring must be closely watched and directed. We must prepare for a strenuous campaign to follow the Convention. Most of us are tired, and would like a brief respite, but when great historical events are massing for revelation, no man may cease his activity, and none may enjoy a furlough.

WHAT SHALL THE ZIONISTS SAY?

ASIDE from the necessary strengthening of the organization we are called upon to deal with the larger problems that have arisen since the outbreak of war. Not only the direct implications of Zionism, but the larger subject of the organization of Jews must receive from us adequate consideration. The Boston convention will be the first national conference of the only functioning international Jewish organization in the world. We have seen how “ably” other organizations have marshalled their forces in this emergency. They have been utter failures. They have not stirred the hearts nor the imaginations of our people. In the midst of the greatest calamity that ever afflicted the Jewish people, they are content with maundering about and repeating old phrases that involve no mental or physical labor. They have practically confessed themselves impotent, and even the distribution of the meagre sum thus far collected for general relief has been directed in the simplest and most irresponsible manner, only to be rid of the difficulties, only to avoid responsibility.

With the old leaders of the Jewish people dazed by what is happening, and covering their confusion with loud protestations of secret influence and power; with not one word of comfort or hope or illumination coming from the lips either of themselves or of their sychophants, it behooves the Zionist organization to take steps to see to it that the Jews in this great crisis shall have leaders equal to the task. At our convention a clear and authoritative word should be spoken. We have no doubt that American Jews are prepared to heed that word, and to act with the Zionists in the realization of a plan of Jewish salvation that measures up to the need and the opportunity.

ELIEZER BEN JEHUDAH.

ELIEZER BEN JEHUDAH should have come to us when we free to pay homage to the great contribution made by him to our national revival, and not when we are engrossed in relieving the material damage done in Palestine by the progress of the war. He should have come to us when everything was normal in Palestine, and when Jewish life could contemplate the fruits of his life work with unalloyed satisfaction.

tion. He comes to us, however, at this time, filled with grief for what is now happening in Palestine. The ces-

sation of all thought of new creations, of new life, of extending the boundaries; the paralyzing of all industry, the crumbling of that promising settlement now devoted simply to the task of maintaining life in whatever there is now there. But we cannot let this occasion pass without a word of sincere greeting to the pioneer who, single-handed, fought the battle for the living Hebrew tongue and by his persistence, his obstinacy, his devotion, forced his views on the budding Jewish settlement in Palestine. What he did was almost superhuman, and least of all would one expect such heroic self-sacrifice of one so weak physically, so frail. But he has in him a great talent for self-immolation. He gave his strength and his power to the Jewish nationality. He gave himself without thought of self, and because he forgot his own interests, the Jewish people will never forget him, and will always treasure his personality, his gift, as one of the finest contributions to the revival of our nationality.

WHY A JEWISH CONGRESS.

WE are glad that a great deal of hot air was liberated in the discussion of the calling of an American Jewish Congress. For out of this heat something of value to Jewish life will be wrought. It has stirred the imagination, it has raised hopes, it has given freedom to the unused Jewish capacity for constructive thought. Without this agitation, had the American Jewish Committee had its way, all this war would have meant would be merely a silent, expressionless, automatic collection of funds which would, as usual have been sent to the Hilfsverein der Deutchen Juden for distribution, and that would have been the end of the matter.

The talk about a Congress has cleared the air. It has made clear the utility of a Congress, and it has also shown what a Congress will not do. What would a Congress produce? A free discussion. That free discussion would have to resolve itself into a set of resolutions whose practical effect would be the election of a representative committee. The discussion would not produce the program. The program would have to be formulated before the discussion was held. It would have to be prepared weeks before the holding of the Congress. In effect, the Congress would, however, place the responsibility for Jewish action upon the Jewish people, and not upon a few self-appointed leaders.

Granting that the Congress could not make the Jewish program, there would, however, be a tremendous gain. The American Jewish community has gradually contracted the basis of its constituency. Autocratic management of Jewish affairs has narrowed the scope of appeal. The firmer the so-called leaders held the reins of government, the fewer were the supporters they could command for any Jewish service. This is to be seen best in the management of institutions, where a small board of directors administering the affairs of the institution gradually concentrate all responsibility and all power in their own hands, and ignore the wishes of the supporters. The American Jewish Committee has selected men in certain communities who have not the confidence of the large mass of Jews in that community. The result is that the community feels no responsibility