the dim instinct of ethnological unity; the frame shattered, the painting faded, and only the coarse, colorless canvas dangling lifelessly in the air. The outcome of this process can be easily foreseen. The ethnological factor may linger on for a little while. But the Jew to whom Judaism is nothing but a brutal fact of nature, who knows nothing of Jewish culture, of Jewish forms of life, of Jewish sentiments and ideals which alone constitute the value, the strength and the reason for existence of the Jewish people, will ultimately refuse to be bound and hampered by the mere accident of birth. Intermarriage will set in, and in some sections of Jewry "it has set in already, and with the disruption of the third and last tie that still keeps these Jewish people together Judaism will soon be a thing of the past.
III.
It is therefore evident that if we wish to preserve the Jewish people and save it from complete annihilation, the only way left to us is once more to revert to the cultural element, to make it again a power in Jewish life and the basic principle of our national existence.
This tremendous task, upon the solution of which depends the further existence of the Jewish people, is greatly complicated by the fact that, while other nationalities, though deprived of a commonwealth of their own, still live in compact masses on their own soil, the Jews are dispersed all over the world and, since they do not and indeed cannot return to their Ghettos, must form part and parcel of the nations in whose midst they live and must fully and actively participate in their life and culture. It is this realization of the additional difficulty of the Jewish dispersion that calls into being the Zionist movement, which endeavors to overcome it by creating a Jewish center on the historic soil of Judaism. That the Zionist solution is logically correct is borne out, far more than by any abstract reasonings, by the actual achievements of the Zionists in Palestine who, in the face of tremendous odds and in spite of the incredible indifference and hostility of the bulk of the Jewish people, have succeeded in creating the beginnings of a Jewish Culture in Palestine, have called into life the first buds of a future Jewish art and have, above all, managed to revive one of the most important vehicles of our national culture, the Hebrew language, which, having existed as a mere literary instrument for nearly two thousand years, is sprouting forth as a living tongue in the mouth of our children in the rejuvenated land of our fathers.
However important and convincing as the Zionist solution undoubtedly is, in the discussion of our problem it can be left out of account. For whatever be the result of the Zionist endeavors, in this all thoughtful Zionists will agree: That the overwhelming majority of our people will continue to live outside of Palestine in the lands of the Diaspora. And while Judaism in the exile will, no doubt, be enormously strengthened and refreshed by the healthy breath of life wafted upon it from a normal, Jewish life in Palestine, it will still be confronted by special problems of its own and above all by the fundamental problem, how to preserve Jewish culture in the midst of a differently constituted environment. It is clear that the solution of this problem can onlv
consist in a compromise between Jewish culture, i. e. between Judaism as a manner of living and mode of thinking, on the one hand, and the culture, i. e. the manner of living and mode of thinking, which we must adopt from our environment, on the other. It will have to be a compromise which is honorable to both sides and will equally safeguard our status as citizens of our respective countries and our position as members of the Jewish nation. It will, no doubt, be a difficult and delicate task, but that it is not impossible of solution may again be illustrated by the Welsh and Scotch who form part and parcel of the political and cultural life of England and yet not only stand out as a sharply marked ethnological entity, but have also managed to preserve and in recent times even to strengthen their own particular cultural life.
And if this great task is to be solved—and solved it must be if Judaism in the exile is to have a chance of life—it can, in my firm belief, nowhere be better solved than in America. Here in the land of the free, in which liberty is not merely freedom from physical shackles, but implies no less freedom of the spirit and the pursuit of happiness, here the Jews, hand in hand with the other nationalities that inhabit our great republic, while fully participating in the political and cultural life of our common country, will strive to preserve their ethnological identity and the great cultural traditions which have made Judaism a power in the world. Our manner of living and mode of thinking will naturally be colored and modified by American life and culture, but they will be strong enough not only to keep the Jews of this country together. but also to link them with the rest of the Jewish people all over the world. It is indeed only in this way, by staunch adherence to its traditions and aspirations, that the Jewish community of America can be of any value to this land and the world beyond it. For a denationalized Jewry, a Jewry without a culture, without any national values of its own, is of utmost indifference to this republic with its vast and rapidly increasing population. But a Jewry which has retained all the vigor and vitality of our race, which fosters and develops its noble traditions—those traditions to which the American nation and civilized humanity owe the best they possess—which, in spite of all vicissitudes and persecutions. has preserved its unparalleled mental elasticity and its ability to produce cultural values in all the domains of life, a Jewry of this type will be a tremendous factor in American life, making for everything that is good and noble, grafting the highest traditions of the oldest of peoples upon the loftiest aspirations of the voungest of nations.
IV.
Finally, if the problem of Jewish culture, which, as will now be realized, is coextensive with the problem of Judaism, the problem of the spiritual life of our people, as distinguished from the problem of Jewry, of the aggregate of Jews and their material welfare, is to be solved in this country, those who will be and ought to be chiefly instrumental in bringing about this solution will be the Jewish college youth of America. For the problem of Jewish culture, though it will eventually involve
(Continued on page 130.)