The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 2 · August 1915
47printed page
scan 2 of 22

by the American Jewish Committee, and would consent only to immaterial changes in that resolution.

And when Mr. Brandeis asked that he convene a special meeting of the American Jewish Committee to reconsider the June 20th resolution in the light of new developments, Dr. Adler declined to do so, and at once sent out invitations to the Conference, thus declaring the peace negotiations at an end.

Dr. Adler further spread broadcast over the land, in the Jewish press, and in communications addressed to individuals and societies, a partial expose of the correspondence, withholding Mr. Brandeis's letters, and seeking to make it appear that the Zionist organization had committed a flagrant breach which necessitated the action taken by him. Dr. Adler thus took the responsibility upon himself to prevent any further negotiations.

A TOOL THAT SERVES.

TH its accustomed lethargy, The American N Hebrew comments upon the correspondence between Mr. Brandeis and Dr. Adler, and in the course of its remarks justifies the position it has attained as the tool that serves the smallest circle of Jews possible, which may be two and may be three, but certainly does not number more than a round dozen of men. Thoughtlessly, with the sole desire of serving its masters, it denounces the Zionists and praises Dr. Adler, and arrives at the strange conclusion that it is Dr. Adler who is the democrat, and the Zionists who are undemocratic, un-American and un-Jewish. Without going deeply into the question, which really deserved careful study by the national Jewish weekly representing the best quality folk in Jewry, The American Hebrew chides the Zionists with interfering with American Jewish Affairs, when on March 26th. the same editor charged the Zionists with not being more interested in American Jewish affairs and with devoting themselves solely to Palestine. He now regards Dr. Adler’s three thousand word letter as an admirable resume of the situation and characterizes Mr. Brandeis’s brief, direct, business-like letters as vague and indefinite.

He forgets, or probably never has heard of the fact that in this Congress issue, the Zionists are merely one organization, and that the Jewish Congress Organization Committee is composed of fourteen national Jewish organizations. He probably has not heard that the Independent Order Berith Abraham, with two hundred thousand members; the Independent Order Berith Sholom with fifty thousand members, the Galician Federation with fifty thousand members, and various other organizations with a total membership of not less than one hundred thousand, have officially at their annual conventions unanimously adopted resolutions in favor of a democratic Congress. He does not know that without stimulation, the radical Jewish workingmen's organizations are now committed to a Congress.

Nor does he know that the Union of American Hebrew Congregations and the Independent Order B’nei Berith are not in accord with Dr. Adler’s ideas of a conference controlled by the American Jewish Committee and limited in the scope of its discussions by a presumptuous resolution adopted bv that Committee on June 20th.

He does not know that the Congress is to be a practical Congress, from which theoretical questions are to be barred, and that the arrangements for the Congress are

to be modelled on the methods and procedure of the American House of Representatives.

There are so many things that fail to make an impression upon The American Hebrew, that their enumeration would take too much of our space.

It is submitted, however, that the small group of men who are being served, gratuitously, by The American Hebrew will see to it that its defenders are more in touch with Jewish affairs, and more capable of a sincere and thoughtful argument that is The American Hebrew. A newspaper which declares that the American Jewish Committee is democratic and American asserts something which even the American Jewish Committee never claimed for itself.

THE MEANING OF THE CONFLICT.

THIS in brief is a resume of the negotiations intended to bring about complete accord in the matter of the Congress. It indicates fairly the stubborn resistance of the few men on the American Jewish Committee who now control its affairs to what is clearly an overwhelming popular demand. Dr. Adler may charge the Zionist organization with “stimulating” the expression of opinion, and the “American Hebrew” with its accustomed sycophancy and thoughtless following of the wishes of the smallest minority it can find in Jewish life, may speak of the methods of professional politicians, but no one who comes in contact with Jews will deny that the Congress movement has the support of the vast majority of American Jews. The American Jewish Committee with the arrogance of men riding for an inevitable fall, not only ignores the mass opinion, but, at this serious juncture, wishes to subordinate to its resolutions organizations of the representative strength of the Independent Order Benai Berith, the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, the Independent Order Berith Abraham, the Independent Order Berith Sholom, and the Federation of American Zionists, and desperately endeavors to impose upon these representative organizations the resolutions adopted by a small group of men who have absolutely no representative standing in Jewish life.

Let no one think that this conflict is merely a conflict which indicates that Jews cannot agree. Jews can agree on principles and policies, and in the matter of the Congress. they are agreed. But owing to the peculiar development of Jewish life in this country, the American Jewish Committee has, without opposition, occupied the immoral position of representing the Jews, tho at no time receiving the mandate so to represent them; and the small group of men who control the American Jewish Committee, having wrested the power it wields from the more representative organizations like the Union of American Hebrew Congregations and the I. ©. B. B., which actually represented the first settlers in America, now refuse to give up that control which they have been exercising in American Jewish affairs for the past ten years. The unity of the Jewish people is being obstructed by the obstinate refusal of the American Jewish Committee to permit the Jewish people to take control of their affairs in their own hands. The consequences of this obstruction rests with the American Jewish Committee. The responsibility for even the appearance of lack of harmony must be shouldered by every member of the American Jewish Committee who permits the wishes of three million people to be frustrated bv less than a dozen men.