Relief Problems Not So Simple
large number of Jews—in most instances not IN Zionists—have been annoyed with the Zionists for intruding with questions that seem to them to be partisan in their inception. Those who have been annoyed must now be disturbed when they read reports brought over here by Mr. Chazanowitz of the uses to which the relief monies sent to Europe by the United States have been put by the Jewish leaders over there. To a large extent, the American Jewish relief committees have abdicated in the distribution of relief in favor of the hitherto unchallenged Jewislf leaders of Germany and Poland, who, provided with large amounts of money, have used the funds at their command to strengthen their positions. The assimilators have not been so nice about the discharge of their trust, but have seen to it that their views should be expressed in the manner of distributing relief. For instance, if a leading Warsaw assimilator had objections to Yiddish, he closed his eyes to the needs of the Yiddish schools, but had them wide open for the needs of the assimilation schools. In Germany, the leading men who are in one way or another connected with the Hilfsverein or its variously named subsidiary organizations, use the funds at their command to deepen the impression made upon the German government that ‘they are the representatives not only of the German Jews but also of the Jews of America; and in the distribution of the funds this intent finds frequent expression. Is it not clear that if American Jewish relief funds are to be distributed on a neutral basis—neutral so far as Jewish policies are concerned—one organization or set of men cannot be permitted to have the controlling voice?
National Workmen's Committee at Last Frankly Against Congress
HE National Workmen’s Committee has been T manoeuvring for about eight months to destroy the Congress movement by prolonged negotiations and scandalous misrepresentations. This manoeuvring it masked by pretending to want unity, but emphasizing the idea of unity not with reference to the Congress, but with reference to Jewish Rights. Feeling that this policy might meet with the approval of the American Jewish Committee, the National Workmen’s Committee seconded every motion made by the former, and made every one of its manoeuvres coincide with the wishes of the leaders of the American Jewish Committee. When, however, the Congress committee formally invited the National Workmen’s Committee to co-operate with the Congress movement, the ruling spirits of that committee responded with the true explanation of all its waverings. It never intended joining the Congress movement. It expected to co-operate in securing Jewish Rights. Nothing further need be said except to cite against the National Workmen’s Committee the explicit resolution adopted by the Workmen’s convention in September, directing the National Workmen’s Committee there elected to join in the calling of a conference to organize a Congress on a democratic basis. The National Workmen’s Committee did not join in calling of a Conference, and now refuses to co-operate in the organization of the Congress. Seldom have radical leaders so flagrantly violated their mandates as have the leaders of the National Workmen’s Committee. We leave them’to settle accounts with their constituents.
Talking to the Point
FOR once, Dr. Samuel Schulman said what was in his mind on Zionism and the Congress so that everybody could understand him. In his article on The Crisis in American Judaism in The American Hebrew, he gives his views with brutal frankness, but clearly. He has no patience with those reform rabbis who are Zionists, for has not the Central Conference of Rabbis repeatedly repudiated Zionism, and is not the Union Prayer Book the record of how Zionism was cut out of the heart of Reform Judaism? The opposition to the Congress comes from those Jews who stand upon a religious platform—religion from the reform standpoint. They are consistently opposed to nationalism and to the introduction of democratic methods in Jewish organization, nor does religious organization require democratic methods. Democratic methods are applicable to political but not to religious institutions. Dr. Schulman states his opinion boldly that the American Jewish Committee, being opposed to nationalism, does not sincerely desire that a Jewish Congress be held but has been forced into a situation where it could not act otherwise. He calls upon that Committee to unite with the I. O. B. B., the Union of American Hebrew Congregations, and the Central Conference of Rabbis, and to act according to its views, regardless of the popular clamor inspired by demagogues and Zionistic misleaders. Dr. Schulman’s arguments, however, depend upon the trustworthiness of his facts. It is doubtful whether reform Jews will agree that opposition to Zionism is a dogma of reform Judaism. It is also a question whether the American Jewish Committee and the I. O. B. B. represent identical points of view. If they did, and their members are high-minded men, without personal ambitions, why is it that they do not unite for action in matters affecting Jewish rights? We agree with Dr. Schulman that the facts being as he states them, it would be to the interests of the Jewish cause if all anti-nationalists were to unite against the efforts to organize the Jewish people through a Congress. We should have less confusion, and more consistent action throughout. We suspect, however, that for such a new alignment the older organizations cannot be regarded as homogeneous factors. The older organizations will have to dissolve and new ones will have to be formed.
The I. O. B. A. Convention
F all the Orders meeting in convention this and ©) next month, the convention of the Independent Order Berith Abraham, because of its size, will receive the greatest attention. The war has brought about a new appreciation of the duty of such large aggregations of organized Jews. In times past, these Orders could «devote their time entirely to their internal affairs, and spend energy and enthusiasm about the elections, etc. Nowadays, new duties present themselves to every Jewish organization. Every Jew feels that in whatever organization he belongs there must come forth from annual assemblies not only a new staff of officers, but also some thing that he can claim will be beneficial to the Jewish people: That is the explanation of the interest displayed last year in all the Orders in the Congress and Zionism. That explains the turmoil produced in the Jewish labor organizations, and the confusion of their leaders, who do not understand the subterranean interest in Jewish affairs of which these were symptoms. In times nast. also. the Orders adopnted resolutions favorable